Just got home from this year's event. I apologize for the length, but I am really annoyed. After much debate, I sprung for the VIP tickets for my mother and myself. In a nutshell: not worth it at all. The regular tix were arguably worthwhile, though given the reports from the Green City Market BBQ, I think that event was still probably a better bet at the same price point. This is not to say that the charity is not worthwhile - in fact, the only thing that's keeping me from being really angry is that it was for a good cause. I don't begrudge the kids the money. However, the extra $55 a ticket for VIP is not a small investment for me, and I hoped to get at least some return out of it, but there was none (in fact, as I'll describe, it was potentially even a loss).
First, the positives (other than the fact that it was a good cause). The various cocktails were of generally very high quality. Special mention to The Drawing Room's alcoholic horchata, In Fine Spirits' gin, coconut water, and lime, and...someone's "Earthy Pisco Sour" with prickly pear, lavender, and sage. The best food I tried.... [(Note: I didn't make it to every stand.) As a side note, there was no A/C in the Aragon, which meant that most places in the space were incredibly warm. The chefs and patrons were sweating up a storm, and at one point, my mother felt she might pass out from the heat, so made a beeline to sit on the stairs. Anyway, it was seriously unappetizingly hot - I know I was very hungry, hadn't eaten very much all day, and still could only stomach a bite of most things.]
Right, the best food. Cibo Matto's octopus was excellent. I really wanted to be able to tell Dale Levitski that his octopus was better, but it just wasn't. L2O's crab "ceviche" with jalapeno-aloe ice, shiso, and yuzu was very clean-tasting and refreshing. Branch 27's shrimp escabeche with elote "salsa" and UrbanBelly's shrimp/watermelon skewer were also great. I think those were pretty much the high points. If I think of any more, I'll add them. On the dessert front, 312 Chicago's peach/sage "Italian ice" with limoncello blueberries was tops for me. There were a lot of corn pudding-type desserts - I'm not sure which was the best, but they were all pretty good.
The negatives, food-wise: Bayless' tacos had WAY too much habanero salsa and blew out my tastebuds for half an hour. Girl and the Goat's goat chilaquiles had way less delicious goat flavor than anything from Zaragoza. The various molecular-gastronomy takes on caprese salad were all less than successful. Other great restaurants put out food that was not notably bad, but also not notably good.
The really negative: the VIP charade. Right from the start, logistically, there was no good demarcation for checking people in, so people were in the wrong lines. Then, after we entered and explored a bit, we asked three different staff members where the VIP lounge was. None of them knew. Two of them said that it was upstairs, to the left of the stage, but that it wouldn't be open until after 9. When we went up to check it out, there were several other people up there, thinking that it was the VIP lounge, and wondering what the deal was with that, so we were not the only people who were confused. We didn't find out where the actual VIP lounge was until almost 10 pm, when I went searching for the restroom. At that point, they told me that it was shutting down, and everyone was to go upstairs, so I still don't know what was in there.
The "afterparty" was a joke. They brought up some of the leftover alcohol from downstairs, but there was no semblance of an actual bar with a selection of drinks available, and there was no food, other than the dregs of some desserts (the pastry section was on the balcony). The iced tea that they were serving up there (that they had been serving all night) was delicious, though. (Also, to negate the value of the "VIP" ticket even more, they were absolutely not checking wristbands at that point).
We left slightly before 11. I had seen some people with the goody bags that had been advertised, and asked them where they'd come from and went looking, but never turned them up (I had seen the "VIP bag" stash on the way in, and looked there, but then was told by some staffer - who was carrying three bags - that they'd be available for us on the way out). On the way out, we ran into another staffer who asked how things had been, and we asked about the goody bags. She told us "Oh, they're all gone. It was 'while supplies last.'" We asked, "Even the VIP ones?" (since most VIPs were still upstairs) and she said yes. That "while supplies last" nonsense was not in the original text regarding VIP tickets. So basically, we paid $55 extra for nothing at all, and perhaps for something less than what the regular ticketholders got, as they all probably received bags as they were ushered out.
Most of the problems could have been solved by better communication and organization by the staff and volunteers. It is really a good cause, so I hope they change their game plan for next year, and make the VIP ticket provide
something of more value than the regular ticket.