Working recently at The Greenhouse (formerly Victory Gardens/Body Politic theatre), I have been hitting Simply It a lot recently.
First I think they have been steadily improving since they opened. The menu tells us that the chef is a former sous from Colonial. (Don't know if this has been true since they opened or not.)
It will never displace Argyle St. There really is no funk here. But if you think of it as Argyle deliberately smoothed down a bit for the Lincoln Ave. audience, but also done with care and integrity, this is probably the best version of that idea that it can be.
Flavors are clear and bright (if mild, as noted above). Ingredients are very fresh. Prices are relatively low and portions generous.
It's not meant to be a back-handed compliment, or faint praise when I say that what the do really well is hospitality.
Owner Tran and his wife (going all the way back to the first Pasteur on Lawrence and Sheridan) are gracious and genuinely friendly. I've watched them work the room, spending as much time as needed to talk with every table and get people who have never eaten this food feeling comfortable with what they're ordering.
They are also very free with the un-ordered lagniappe, which makes people feel cared for.
I was recently picking up some take out for which I had phoned ahead. It was an off-the-charts Saturday, and the food wasn't quite ready when I arrived. While attending to his full room, and his line of waiting customers, he also produced a cool glass of water for me, immediately followed by a complete appetizer of fried vegetable egg rolls. Just to make up for my 5-10 min. wait.
Every time i have dined in we have received either a chicken salad, or a house-made lemonade or ice tea on the house.
Yes they do a version of pho, and all the condiments are fresh and crisp, but it's certainly not for the well-initiated. It's a nice bowl of soup.
So far I have very much enjoyed:
* the grilled lemongrass beef
* the Saigon crepe, large and very tasty
* the North Vietnam Fisherman's soup---a very nice amount of heat with this broth
* the tofu/eggplant in clay pot (major garlic presence, and that nice carmelized clay pot goodness)
* lemongrass chicken (nice heat, could use more lemongrass intensity)
* curry chicken (only observed and smelled this over a colleague's shoulder, but he was very happy
*Chicken salad: just the barest prickle of heat, but lovely fresh crispy crunchy cabbage and good chicken
* Tiramisu (I know, but I wanted a sweet and it was good.)
* The "complimentary" fruit comes with both take-out and dine in and every single time each piece has been deliciously sweet and ripe, not just an afterthought.
One item that is curiously hyped on the menu as a "chef's choice" or something like that,
gets its own box and everything, is a roll called "Fresh, fresh, fresh!" Looked promising in description but just didn't come together for me. Julienned asparagus, tofu, carrot, jicama (maybe something else), wrapped in seaweed, then wrapped again in rice paper. Served with 2 dipping sauces: a tamarind, and another more like plum sauce. Both basically sweet. Essentially there was no melding. Every one of the ingredients just sat there in the roll next to its mates but remained untransformed in any way. A swing and a miss.
It's not Tank Noodle or a Cafe Hoang, but if you're on Lincoln Ave. amid the DePaul bars and big screen TVs and Barleycorn's and McDonald's and Bacinos and a couple of taco places and the Athenian Room is a solid 10 min. walk away and you're a grown-up, then Simply It is where you want to go.
"Strange how potent cheap music is."