I was taken to Fork last night for a lovely Valentine's surprise dinner. I had only been to Fiddlehead once for brunch and never was interested in going back for dinner. When it was SquareKitchen I went quite often, I found it to be a reliable casual place. I was excited to try the "new concept", they are now trying to be a more beer focused gastropub.
Because it was Valentine's Day they only offered a 3 course Prix Fixe menu with an optional wine or beer pairing for $16 extra. My date and I both chose the wine pairing because we weren't in the mood for beer. We didn't know they were only offering the limited menu before showing up, but since the options looked good we were not disappointed.
Sorry I did not bring my camera, but I was very impressed with most of the food. We decided to pick different course options and share:
Course 1: Oysters Rockefeller and Braised Beef Cheeks
The Oysters Rockefeller was a large portion, 4 large oysters, they were delicious and the champagne sauce was excellent
The Beef Cheeks were very tender, prepared with bacon and spinach I believe, over creamy polenta. It was a little salty for my taste, but I still enjoyed it
Course 2: Lamb Duo (Rack & Braised) and Beef Duo (Beef Pot Pie and Petite Filet)
The lamb was excellent...the braised lamb shoulder prepared with a Moroccan spice mixture and candied oranges was very good; the rack of lamb was perfectly cooked and the glaze was delicious
The beef pot pie was made with braised short rib and had a great puff pastry top on it, I didn't try the petite filet but was told it was a basic filet, nothing too special
Course 3: French Chocolate Cake and Apple Tart
Both were good, but I was so stuffed I could barely eat much of it. The French chocolate cake was a typical flourless chocolate cake, the apple tart was quite good, though I didn't love the cinnamon ice cream.
I have to say that the pairings with each course were excellent, particularly the 1st and 3rd courses, I was very impressed. I believe the apple tart was paired with a sparkling muscat and the chocolate cake was paired with a special Semillon.
Service wasn't great. It took nearly ten minutes for the waiter to come over after we had been seated (he stopped by briefly after 6 minutes or so to say he'd be right back); he didn't really check on us after our courses had been delivered until we were at least halfway through and our 3rd course arrived several minutes before our pairing. It wasn't really very busy, so I'm not sure if they were just adjusting to the new format or if it was because we were way in the back. Also, my date was told they only had 830pm available for reservations, we showed up around 8pm thinking we could grab a drink and at least try to get seated early and the place was only 1/2 full. We were seated immediately, but were wondering if they were trying to purposely only partially fill the place.
I would definitely go back again and check out their regular menu, despite the kinks in service, the food was very good!