Somehow, I've lived in north Lincoln Park for almost a decade yet never tried La Gondola. When I first noticed it on a trip to Jewel, I assumed it was some run of the mill Italian joint. Even after I'd read good things, I'd always forget when trying to think of a place to go out & eat. When they had a Groupon a couple months ago, I bought it figuring it'd finally compel me to try the place. A couple times, I'd tried to book for same day or next day and couldn't get a reservation... not so surprising considering they only have 5-6 tables. So I book a reservation for 8pm tonight about a week ago...
Anyway, my wife got stuck at work late and we didn't end up arriving until 9pm (at one point, I called and said we'd be there about 8:20-8:30). When they couldn't seat us until 10pm and we were starving, they offered to waive the dine-in only on the Groupon so we got carry outs. After studying the menu and asking for recommendations, we ended up ordering Rigatoni Boscaiola (cream tomato sauce, mushroom, sausage), Chicken Monte Carlo (white wine sauce, eggplant, roasted red pepper, broccoli) and a thin crust pepperoni pizza. Got a choice of soup or salad with the two entrees. Had a nice chat with the owner (?) and waiter while waiting, and my wife enjoyed glass of wine. They handed us a bag of food and we walked out, got in our car & drove off... they'd forgotten our pizza and had one of their employees chase us down at a red light to give it to us! Every one of their staff couldn't have been more friendly and helpful.
Arriving home, we finally got to enjoy our dinner. And we thoroughly enjoyed everything. The pasta was tasty, cooked to perfection and not too rich. The chicken was moist and the veggies in the dish were flavorful. The white wine sauce was a little bland, but given the flavor of the pasta and pizza, it was a fine balance. Really liked the pizza. Thin, but not too thin with a crispy crust that could withstand more cheese than normally found on a think crust pizza. About to heat up the leftovers for lunch and can't wait to enjoy it all again!
Now, I'm just sorry it took us so long to check La Gondola out. I know a lot of restaurants don't think Groupons work, and perhaps they usually don't. But this is a case where it worked exactly as they're supposed to. Got us through the door and won us over so we'll definitely be back soon and often.