So I ended up going to NY B&B, they do not have doughnuts - but like I said, in general their baked goods are pretty sad looking so I didn't expect anything.
I decided to go with Lee Donut in Libertyville - an old standby that I forgot about. Being in Libertyville (my destination) made it very convenient.
Not to mention, they have some KILLER donuts. Everything is made fresh on sight - the cake donuts have a nice crisp outside with a moist interior, and the glazed are light as a feather. And, at well under $1.00 each (my threshold for reasonable donut cost) the total cost of 8 with tax was just over $5.00
I guess I didn't really follow through with what I was asking for, but man was I pleased with my purchase.
Lee Donut
124 Peterson Road
Libertyville, IL 60048
(847) 816-7764