The s/o has a full family in da U.P. Mom, dad, sister, cousins, nieces, nephews, assorted friends, grandfolk - the whole shebang. This means that several times a year, we load up one of the seebee mobiles, and make the 6 to 7+ hour pilgrimmage. Been doing this for 10 years now, and for 10 years, we either pack a few sammiches and snacks, or stop for roadfood on the way. The usual roadfood consists of Subway, McDonalds, but recently, it's been Jimmy John's or Taco John's. Yes, Taco John's is well, um, not great, but I like their salsa bar - the verde can be screamin hot sometimes

. I've pretty much given up on Subway, their "roasted chicken" was the only thing I would eat there, and now they've changed it from real chicken to a foamy, chicken like substance which is a deal breaker in my book. Jimmy John's I used to like ten years ago, but their roast beef is now just an oversalty mess, so I tend to shy away. So anyway, we got off at the Lineville exit near Green Bay for gas and eats a few trips ago, and I saw a sign for BBQ. Bates City BBQ. I figured what the hey. Something different. I was not expecting much at all, but just, something different. Worth a shot. Something different. Anything different.
I'd classify this as a "score."
This is smoked bbq.
This is my new "go to" spot for our trips. This is some pretty decent, quick off/on the expressway eats. Granted, I have never tried Rocky Racocco's pizza, or Hardees, or Beanos, but I don't think I'll ever be stopping at Jimmy John's or Taco John's, or Mcd's on our trips ever again unless we're driving at a time when Bates City BBQ is closed, or we are already sated. Is this great food? NO. Is it the best bbq ever? NO. Is it the best food I've found that is really quick to grab on a road trip while driving through Wisconsin on 94 or US 141 / 41 or whatever it is? Yes, by a wide, wide margin. And the prices are very decent, to boot. The ability to gas up, and get real bbq a scant 1/2 mile or so from the exit? Count me in as a fan.
Now, Like I said, this isn't GREAT stuff (although we all know about bbq consistency - maybe they have some days where some things are great.)
I'll give a rundown on what we've had and liked, and disliked.
Disliked the turkey. I envisioned the Texas Cue joints' smoked turkey when I saw they had turkey on the menu. For those unfamiliar with the Texas joints, well, I feel for you. I ordered Bates City BBQ's "turkey sandwich" and it was that stuff. That stuff that people call "deli turkey" for some reason. It was not turkey. I was not happy. Live and learn. I'll just leave it at that.
Disliked the potato salad. It was that sugary glop. It wasn't bad like the Orville Kent or Reeser's glop. It looked like it was prolly made in house. Waaay too sweet for me. I don't understand the lure of sugary potato salad, never will.
The last time I went, I ordered the mixed plate, and chose brisket as one of the meats. I ate it all, but it was dry. Like real dry. I'm not sure if any self respecting pitmaster would have served that to anyone. Real dry. I'll assume that is not the norm. I'll probably try it again.
The beans. Well, I could learn to love these beans here. If they were about 1/3 to 1/2 less sweet than they were, they might have been stellar. Still, I happily ate them, and liked them, but they were borderline shockingly sweet. Personal preference on sweetness, but I gotta say, the flavors were outstanding save for the sweetness. Definitely getting these again.
Pulled pork: this was just chunks of smoked pork. Decent. When I think of pulled pork, I'm thinking the moist juicy shreds. This was more along the lines of small pork chunks. It was ok.
Chicken: Liked it a lot. Much better on the bone as like a half or whole chicken. They will pull it for you, and make a sandwich, or serve it pulled as a choice on a "mixed plate," but after trying it both ways, I'd stick to a half chicken.
Spares: These are big ol Flintstone spares with tip attached. I had ribs both times we went, and I will always get them each time we go. They are decent. Not meat jello - definitely smoked q. Both times, the rib meat held up on the bone and had a decent chew, but it was possible to pull a good chuck of meat off with one bite. I prefer a more chewy rib, but I don't have anything really bad to say about these.
French Fries: I'm not a big fry person, but these things are some of the best fries I've ever had. These are like a cross between Parky's and Gene and Jude's and I am not kidding one bit. They are a little bit thicker cut than Parky's, thinner than Gene&Judes, and fried well. They know what they are doing with fries at this joint. Like, seriously. Both times, I just ordered "fries" - didn't have to specify "well done" or "extra crunchy." These fries are the bees' knees.
Sauce - I've seen two kinds. mild and hot. LOVE the hot. Both are tomato based, and probably compare to commercial brands like bullseye or kc masterpiece the most, although the Bates sauce is a litte runnier. The hot sauce floats my boat here. It's not hot like the unforgiveable heat of Uncle JOhn's, but it is a subtle sizzle that put a bead of sweat on my forehead after prolonged exposure last time. The meat is definitely not held "in sauce" but the sauce is poured on top of your order. Of the two times I went, the food was never bathing in sauce. Next time, I might ask for no sauce, and then use the bottles on thje counter to sauce my own.
I am happy as all get out to have stopped here. Ribs, chicken, fries and beans will be my baseline order here, and the prices are right. (Love the "add a rib" for 1.69 option) I think for two ppl, a 1/2 chicken dinner with fries, 2 or 3 ribs, and maybe a small side of beans would be a phenomenal deal coming in right around 10 to 12 bux. I am all about this place for quick roadfood if driving through.
Menu:

Briskets:

Choppin up some burnt ends:


I'm guessing pork shoulders?

Birds. Juicy and Smokey:

Resting rack for the Q:

The fries. I'm tellin you these fries are stellar. The picture is a close up, they are thinner cut than they appear here:

Mixed plate. Really bad (in car) picture:

If you're passing through, I think this place is VERY decent all in all. Ribs, bone in chicken, fries, and beans are quite solid indeed considering price, and the fact that it's just off the expressway in Green Bay somewhere.
http://www.bcbarbque.com/
We cannot be friends if you do not know the difference between Mayo and Miracle Whip.