My wife and I have long been fans of Sweets and Savories. We've taken many out-of-town guests there, including a couple larger groups. Sweets has always impressed with their warm service and excellent value. Also, while I'm sure David Richards has earned much of the bad ink spilled about him, in our experiences he has always been gracious and generous, comping us a plate or a dessert on a number of occasions. So I take no joy in writing about how far they've fallen.
We made it out to Sweets last Friday night. The dining room was half full so the servers were particularly attentive. The prices have increased, but I always felt that the value was so good that we weren't deterred by the increase to 36 dollars for three courses.
To start off we ordered the mussel appetizer, the pea and mushroom risotto, and the polenta gnocchi (I always sub an app for a dessert). The mussels were rubbery and their sauce tasted of uncooked wine, we could barely finish it. The risotto featured flavorless, clearly frozen peas, and a lifeless white sauce that drowned the risotto into a bland, mushy pile. The gnocchi had decent texture, but the butter sauce was unremarkable. Sadly, this mediocre offering was the highlight of the meal.
Then came the entrees. The butter-poached lobster risotto, something we've ordered at least 5 times before, had a fraction of the lobster we're used to and was identical in flavor and texture to the risotto we had as an appetizer. My wife was visibly shocked by how much worse the lobster risotto was than before. The pork tenderloin was served cold with a from-the-bottle quality, cloyingly sweet barbecue sauce and a dense, hard, corn cake that was cold like it came straight from the refrigerator. This one we couldn't finish.
When the waitress came to ask how the meal was, we could barely muster a kind response. We begrudgingly ordered the meyer lemon tart for dessert. It tasted like it was bought at the Jewel down the street.
I sincerely hope this doesn't mark the end for one of our favorite restaurants. Perhaps they've had some turnover in the kitchen after their hiatus in late January. Whatever the issue is, we won't be back unless we hear others have a much better experience than we did.