Well, I am pleased to say my 2nd pizza was INFINITELY better than my first attempt.
Every single characteristic of the pizza was outstanding, at least by my inexperienced pizza-palate. I'm sure there is plenty more improvement to go, but I was really happy with the pie.
I used fresh dough from Mariano's and topped it with whole canned tomatoes (cleaned) brought from Graziano's - I forget what brand, but Mrs. Graziano said they were "from the San Marzano region" but was insistent they were not San Marzanos (as if I thought she was trying to rip me off or something...haha). Regardless they were great, mashed and drained, and lightly seasoned. Thanks mhill95149 for the suggestion!
On top of that was freshly shredded scamorza cheese (also from Mariano's), fresh sliced pepperoni (from Graziano's), and a light dusting of pecorino romano.
At the behest of Mrs. Graziano, I par-baked the the un-topped crust for about 2 minutes (she would not let go of my arm until I agreed to do so - really). It really helped keep everything crisp and allow no moisture to invade the crust, even though using fresh tomatoes means there is extra liquid, no matter how long I drain it.
The scamorza was creamy with a little bite from the provolone-type flavor in contributes, and the fresh pepperoni had a terrific kick to it and added the additional salt-kick the pizza needed.
The pizza came out in about 10 minutes perfectly browned and the crust had that certain chew to it I always look for (and usually don't find) in a NY slice.
Hot damn, I look forward to seeing what happens if and when I start making my own dough.
One question: what is the recommended technique for folding over dough to make the crust? About half the crust was neat, and the other half I had trouble getting the fold to hold. I think I may have used a little too much flour on the bench, which could inhibit the dough sticking together - is that possible? Any other suggestions?
It is a small thing, and the pizza tasted great regardless, but I'd like to get it a little nicer looking for next time.
Thanks!