ronnie_suburban wrote:A few of my work-mates stopped in today and enjoyed what they ate but also felt it was a bit pricey, especially compared to Pita Inn-Skokie, which is in our regular lunch rotation. I'm looking forward to checking Naf Naf out next week.
=R=
seebee wrote:ronnie_suburban wrote:A few of my work-mates stopped in today and enjoyed what they ate but also felt it was a bit pricey, especially compared to Pita Inn-Skokie, which is in our regular lunch rotation. I'm looking forward to checking Naf Naf out next week.
=R=
If you have access to a Pita Inn during weekday lunch-time hours, not much ANYWHERE (Mid-Eeastern or not) is gonna compare to the BLS if that's what your work mates get. I usually wind up at the Pita Inn Wheeling at least once a week for the special, and it rarely disappoints, and is generally stellar for the price. If Naf Naf was side by side to a Pita Inn, I'd choose Pita Inn for the value and quality, but naf-naf's pita and their lentil soup with a healthy dollop of their hot sauce is what I think is really special about the place. The falafel and chicken shawarma are both very decent as well. I don't think the Naf is gonna blow you away, but those Israeli pitas will have you second guessing Pita Inn once in a while. If I'm ever out in Naperthrill, Naf Naf is definitely on my mind for the soup and the pitas. First time I went, I thought it was overpriced as well, but those pitas and that soup...kinda droolworthy. I stick to soup with hot sauce, baba ghanouj with falafel, and a chicken shawarma sandwich for two ppl. I've had a few other menu items, and well..yeah...that's what I stick with.
cilantro wrote:We tried Naf Naf a couple of weeks ago. I think the most relevant comparison is not to Pita Inn (which I agree this is superior to in almost every way except price) but rather Mizrahi Grill in Highland Park. Keeping in mind that I have eaten at Mizrahi many, many times and at Naf Naf only once, the following are some initial observations:
Shawarma
Naf Naf's is chicken, whereas Mizrahi's is a turkey/lamb mixture. Whether due to ingredients, cooking method, or both, Naf Naf's shawarma is much juicier, at the expense of crispness. Naf Naf's is also spiced much more assertively.
I'd say it's a draw here because even though Naf Naf's meat is more flavorful, to me crispy bits are an essential element of good shawarma.
(Both shawarmas, incidentally, were absolutely blown out of the water by an amazing crisp-and-juicy number I recently pretty much inhaled at Judah Mediterranean Grill in Philadelphia.)
Falafel
Again, Naf Naf's is moister but lacking the crisp shell of really good falafel. But the flavor itself is bold and herbal; I quite enjoy Mizrahi's falafel, but I think I liked this more.
Pita
Very similar, but I believe Naf Naf's is slightly larger and not as thick. Both are very good and it's hard to choose between them.
Toppings
Here, Mizrahi wins hands down. Naf Naf gives you the standard tahini/hummus/Israeli salad and there are pickles on the side which you are free to apply yourself. Mizrahi has all those and also adds cabbage salad and fries to the mix. (Theoretically, you could also request one or more of their other salads as toppings, although I've never tried this.) Sometimes I feel like fries and sometimes I don't, but the cabbage salad is an important part of making the overall sandwich come together. Naf Naf has containers of hot sauce already portioned out, à la Pita Inn; you have to request it at Mizrahi. The hot sauces are also different -- Naf Naf's is thinner and pourable, whereas Mizrahi's is more of a paste. Both are very good.
Price
I believe Naf Naf is somewhat cheaper across the board.
Hmm... I feel like I should have some sweeping conclusion here, but I seem to have run out of steam. I still prefer Mizrahi, but it's a very close call. Mizrahi does have more options, especially as far as appetizers, soups, and salads. While the falafel I tried at Naf Naf was close to my Platonic ideal, the overall sandwich at Mizrahi appeals more to me. I would guess that although I'll end up being a regular at both, most of the time I'll be taking that extra 15-minute drive up Edens.
2146 north wrote:Maybe Im and old guy so soft food is fine, but I loved loved loved the falafel sandwich. The at first the softness surprised me, but then I really found the flavor of them to be really pleasing, along with the condiments made for a very tasty sandwich. The hot sauce was very good, it gave a nice heat to the food, not instant but a growing increase in heat. The place is pricey (compared to again....... Pita Inn) but being close to my office is a place I will add to a much less frequent rotation of places I eat out at for lunch. I also was sorry not to see lemon available, to add to my tea.
ronnie_suburban wrote:I don't know if Pita Inn has lemons but frankly, their food doesn't need them, so I've never asked.
=R=
BR wrote:I had my first visit to this location (have never been to the Naperville location) and I have to say I was a little underwhelmed. The biggest disappointment to me was the falafel sandwich. The whole sandwich was just too mushy in every respect. The falafel were flavorful enough and seemed fresh, but there wasn't any crispness to them and they were even slightly undercooked in the middle. Coupled with the pita bread which is ultra-soft, the whole thing was just too mushy. Now I realize many are a fan of their pitas, and yes it's baked fresh, but this very fluffy-style pita is just not really my thing. But that's really my issue; the mushy falafel is Naf Naf's though and it must be fixed. (The accompanying french fries - or cottage fries if you will - were quite enjoyable though.)
I also tried the chicken shawarma sandwich and aside from my general lack of enthusiasm for the pita, I thought it was decent. I prefer the slightly more aggressive seasoning of some of the places on Kedzie, as well as the crispier bits which were largely lacking, but it was certainly a moist sandwich and decent.
Finally, baba ganoush was fine, although I think the eggplant could be improved by a deeper roasting.
Staff was friendly enough and when I'm back in the area I might consider a return to try some different menu items, but my lunch experience won't have me going out of my way for a return visit.
BR wrote:It's certainly never going to be my favorite Middle Eastern restaurant, but given their Chipotle-esque decor/style, I can probably get some of my non-adventurous food friends here without a battle (bringing back memories of Marge Simpson investigating possible restaurant franchises, exploring the Middle Eastern concept, where they called tahini "flavor sauce" . . . loved that!).
One of the lessons learned from the newsgroup rec.food.cooking econs ago was the parsley component in tabbouleh varies widely country to country, region to region. Main thing I learned from rec.food.cooking is that heritage eaters will argue forever about nuance and every single one of them is 100% convinced they are abso-f'n-lutely correct.GAF wrote:My biggest disappointment with Naf Naf was the tabbouleh salad. In my experience an excellent tabbouleh should be a nice balance of parsley and bulgur wheat (with some mint, cucumber and tomato), but Naf Naf's version was almost entirely parsley salad. I would not recommend it.
BR wrote:BR wrote:I had my first visit to this location (have never been to the Naperville location) and I have to say I was a little underwhelmed. The biggest disappointment to me was the falafel sandwich. The whole sandwich was just too mushy in every respect. The falafel were flavorful enough and seemed fresh, but there wasn't any crispness to them and they were even slightly undercooked in the middle. Coupled with the pita bread which is ultra-soft, the whole thing was just too mushy. Now I realize many are a fan of their pitas, and yes it's baked fresh, but this very fluffy-style pita is just not really my thing. But that's really my issue; the mushy falafel is Naf Naf's though and it must be fixed. (The accompanying french fries - or cottage fries if you will - were quite enjoyable though.)
I also tried the chicken shawarma sandwich and aside from my general lack of enthusiasm for the pita, I thought it was decent. I prefer the slightly more aggressive seasoning of some of the places on Kedzie, as well as the crispier bits which were largely lacking, but it was certainly a moist sandwich and decent.
Finally, baba ganoush was fine, although I think the eggplant could be improved by a deeper roasting.
Staff was friendly enough and when I'm back in the area I might consider a return to try some different menu items, but my lunch experience won't have me going out of my way for a return visit.
Naf Naf has now opened in Rosemont (near the Allstate Arena). Including a couple of soon-to-be locations, they'll soon have 8 locations. The assembly line procedure reminds me of Chipotle quite a bit, but I'll admit that I enjoyed my first visit to the Rosemont location far more than my only other Naf Naf visit. Chicken shawarma was tasty (though I still don't love the fluffy pita, but this pita was slightly less fluffy than I recall). Also, I had a falafel on the side and this was far better than the falafel I had on my first visit (Niles). Hot, crisp, and very well seasoned. I thought their seasoned rice was very good too.
It's certainly never going to be my favorite Middle Eastern restaurant, but given their Chipotle-esque decor/style, I can probably get some of my non-adventurous food friends here without a battle (bringing back memories of Marge Simpson investigating possible restaurant franchises, exploring the Middle Eastern concept, where they called tahini "flavor sauce" . . . loved that!).
fropones wrote:I really liked the fully automated shawarma slicers they have
groovedirk wrote:Reading some of the other postings I'm surprised not everybody loves the "fluffy" pita at Naf Naf Grill. I think it's fantastic and is the main reason I drop by. I do like their hummus and some other bits as well, but living close to Dhawarma and Semiramis --amongst others--the pita is what won me over. Whenever I goto the Costco in Niles (quite often it turns out) its hard for me not to drop by for that pita....
ronnie_suburban wrote:groovedirk wrote:Reading some of the other postings I'm surprised not everybody loves the "fluffy" pita at Naf Naf Grill. I think it's fantastic and is the main reason I drop by. I do like their hummus and some other bits as well, but living close to Dhawarma and Semiramis --amongst others--the pita is what won me over. Whenever I goto the Costco in Niles (quite often it turns out) its hard for me not to drop by for that pita....
I agree. There are a few other items I enjoy at Naf Naf but their pita is my favorite item, and the only item there I consider truly destination-worthy.
=R=
BR wrote:ronnie_suburban wrote:groovedirk wrote:Reading some of the other postings I'm surprised not everybody loves the "fluffy" pita at Naf Naf Grill. I think it's fantastic and is the main reason I drop by. I do like their hummus and some other bits as well, but living close to Dhawarma and Semiramis --amongst others--the pita is what won me over. Whenever I goto the Costco in Niles (quite often it turns out) its hard for me not to drop by for that pita....
I agree. There are a few other items I enjoy at Naf Naf but their pita is my favorite item, and the only item there I consider truly destination-worthy.
=R=
The Wonder Bread of pitas . . . in this man's opinion. But that's what makes this board interesting, right?