
I shared a few bottles with some friends this past weekend (2007-2011 Bourbon County Stout as well as the Rare (2010), Vanilla (2010) and the 2010 Coffee versions). While it would have been nice to have the most recent variations (2011 Bramble Rye and 2011 Coffee), as you can see, we had plenty. The Rare, Vanilla and 2010 Coffee were opened last and I'm sure our palettes were sufficiently blown by that point that the more subtle nuances were totally lost on us. Rare was noticeably different (in a good way) than any of the others, though, so it was still a joy to drink and something I look forward to revisiting soon without the additional beers beforehand. The Vanilla didn't seem as distinctive to me as it once did -- it was still very good and probably just sweeter than the rest but I couldn't exactly pinpoint a vanilla flavor. The Coffee has suffered the most (unsurprisingly). While the aroma still had a nice coffee punch, the body and finish only had the bitter notes I associate more with coffee grounds than an entire cup of coffee. The 2011 version has just been bottled and if it's anywhere near as good as the 2010 was when it was freshly bottled, it will already be a contender for my favorite beer of 2012. It will be a royal PITA to find but should be entirely worth it.
As for the '07-'11 vintages of the regular BCBS, they were all very good. Sitting next to the younger vintages, the '07 probably suffered the most, but really only by comparison. The flavors were just more muted and tasted flatter overall (not just in terms of carbonation). The '11 came out stronger than in past years (14.5% vs 13%), and it was pretty apparent. I prefer by bourbon-barrel stouts to be pretty bourbon-forward, so I really enjoyed the '11 -- others preferred something a little more mellow. The '09 and '10 were pretty similar to me -- wonderfully mellow, still boozy, thick, full body, lingering finish, etc. The '08 stood out just a touch more than the '09 and '10 for me, though - like it had a more structured body, if nothing else.
If anyone missed the December release of the 2011 Bourbon County Stout, Goose is saying there will be another batch some time in February. I wouldn't be surprised if the Bramble Rye, 2011 Coffee and this second batch are released at the same time, even though that would be something of a perfect storm for retailers. The swath of destruction left in the path of roving hordes of beer nerds in search of these three beers... it won't be pretty!
best,
dan