In terms of upscale dining with more local fare, Juban's is pretty widely considered to be tops in Baton Rouge. I have never actually dined in there, but have been to events catered by Juban's and everything was very good. Do not let the location (in a strip mall) throw you.
Juban's
3739 Perkins Road
225-346-8422
http://www.jubans.com/Moving to more everyday options, Sammy's is a pretty popular seafood place (fried dishes, fresh seafood preps, boiled crawfish and crabs in season -- in a pretty laid-back setting), and I have had a number of very good meals there. I believe Donald Link (Herbsaint, Cochon) got his start cooking there when in college at LSU. Pretty expansive menu can lead to a little hit-and-miss, but the servers usually can steer you to good options.
Sammy's Grill
8635 Highland Road (2 other locations as well)
225-766-9600
http://www.sammysgrillonline.com/I have written about George's
here. Really good poboys, plus rotating specials that are worth checking out. Good place for a few cold ones and some Louisiana-style bar fare. Never you mind the right-wing bumper stickers and signage (nothing horribly offensive, as far as I can recall).
George's
2943 Perkins Road
225-343-2363
http://www.georgesbr.com/ORIGINAL/For an interesting (and to my taste, very good) style of pizza (not that you would necessarily be inclined to go for pizza in Baton Rouge), in a dive of a cocktail bar, Fleur-de-Lis pizza is a one-of-a-kind place. Wright Thompson
waxed poetically on it recently over at Grantland.
Fleur-de-Lis Cocktail Lounge
5655 Government St
225-924-2904
www.fleurdelispizza.com Together with Juban's, Mansur's on the Boulevard is another one in the more upscale dining category. Some local specials plus steakhouse fare (although with Louisiana touches). Pretty good wine list too.
Mansur's on the Boulevard
5720 Corporate Blvd #A
225-923-3366
mansursontheboulevard.com In the aftermath of Katrina, a handful of New Orleans restaurants opened locations in Baton Rouge. There used to be an outpost of Galatoire's in Baton Rouge, but I believe it is relocating and is closed. There is an Acme Oyster House on Perkins Road in Baton Rouge, but I've not been there (based on location and what the building looks like -- i.e., would not be out of place in the corner of a mall parking lot -- I suspect anyone going looking for a recreation of the New Orleans experience might be disappointed, but I would guess the product is probably as good as that in N.O.).
In terms of the drive back to New Orleans, try to make a stop at
Wayne Jacob's/WJ's Smokehouse in La Place if you get a chance.
[Edited to correct a couple of typos]
Last edited by
Matt on January 30th, 2012, 3:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.