We were staying somewhere outside of Syracuse on Sunday and the hotel desk staff, who might just have wanted us to spend our $$ in the overpriced mediocre hotel restaurant, told us that we wouldn't find anything other than a few chains open on a Sunday night. Well, after a long, hard day, Sweet Baboo wanted some steak, and wouldn't have minded if the only place to get that was at Outback Steakhouse. He gave me just a few minutes to search, and I found, with the help of Yelp, a better option: a place in in Dewitt, NY, just on the south side of Syracuse, a great little place called the Dark Horse Tavern.
The bartender confirmed that they were one of the few local places open on Sunday nights. It's a very attractive, dark but warmly lit, cozy place, with a bar and about a dozen booths, with a great selection of wines, and really fine food. After regretfully ruling out steamed clams and sautéed scallops and shrimp cocktail (I said it was a long, hard day; by the time we got there, we wanted to eat everything!), we decided to share a crab-and-lobster cake appetizer; we both had the delicious sirloin steak with fried onions and homemade garlic mashed potatoes and gravy; we enjoyed the delicious warm bread that was served to us with olive oil and cheese and spices for the oil, and I tried a white and a red wine, both very good. The staff there was so friendly to us and appreciative that as travelling tourists we had picked their restaurant for the evening, and at the end they surprised us by bringing us a big wedge of chocolate-iced chocolate layer cake to take with us. They refused to let us pay for the dessert, so we tried to make it up to them in the tip. We also learned that under one management or another, the Dark Horse Tavern had been a GNR for that neighborhood for more than 50 years, and that many of the locals eat there several times a week.
Dark Horse Tavern
4312 East Gennessee Street
Dewitt, NY
"Your swimming suit matches your eyes, you hold your nose before diving, loving you has made me bananas!"