We tried Pizzeria Neo on Friday (on one of our relatively infrequent "date nights"). As noted in the prior review, the atmosphere and decor are very trendy and modern. Though that's not really my thing, I think that a place like this is a nice addition to the downtown Naperville scene.
IMHO, the salumi bar is the highlight of this place with the pizzas coming in second. We picked the "medium" sampler, which allowed us to pick a combination of six meats/cheeses/vegetables (grilled eggplant was excellent). Along with the eggplant, we had prosciutto, two types of salami, parmigiano and aged asiago. The meats, cheeses and eggplant were nicely presented, came with bread, and were very, very good. I know that this isn't a novel concept, by any means. But, surprisingly, there aren't any other Italian restaurants in the Western burbs (that I am aware of) that focus on serving salumi in this manner. We really like the concept.
Our two pizzas were good, but not great. I prefer Neopalitan-style pizza to have a nice crisp crust. Our pizzas were somewhat soggy and the crust became droopy and was overpowered by tomato sauce (on the Margherita). Perhaps we caught them on a bad night.
The wine list was a little on the pricey side, but the house Chianti was reasonably priced and not bad.
I really do like this place, and would be willing to give their pizzas another try. In any case, we definitely will be back to the bar for the salumi.