This is not my favorite style of pizza but a fantastic dinner here about a week ago prompted me to return for lunch yesterday. Unfortunately, the lunch wasn't as enjoyable as the dinner. At the first meal, everything sang. Crusts were typically wonderful and the toppings were sensational in every way. The pizzas were out of this world, as was just about everything we tried, even pastas. We tried 3 excellent pizzas, including the Bufalina (tomatoes, basil, mozzarella di bufala, olive oil) and the Funghi e Salsiccia (tomatoes, mozzarella, mushrooms, sausage, basil, olive oil). However, one pizza -- a sublime tuna and pepperoni combination that must have been a special -- haunted me all week. I couldn't stop thinking about how good it was, nor telling everyone I knew about it. Unfortunately, at yesterday's lunch, it was nowhere to be found. Still, we were easily able to find a couple other combinations that looked appetizing -- it's a great menu. But first, we started with a salad . . .
Rucola e Parmiggiano Salad | arugula, shaved parmiggiano, extra virgin olive oil, fresh lemon
We really enjoyed the peppery, bouncy-fresh arugula but we both found this salad to be way over-salted.
Mare & Monti | tomatoes, mozzarella, baby shrimp, porcini mushrooms, olive oil, parsley
There was a lot to like about this pizza. The dough itself was spot on. It had a crispy exterior and a chewy interior. The complex flavor built throughout the chew. The plump baby shrimp were perfectly cooked and fresh-tasting. But the overall flavor of the ingredients atop the crust was bland and the tomatoes tasted a bit watery. I realize that this style of pizza is more about the crust than the toppings but in comparison to the pizzas I had on my first visit, this was somewhat flat.
Mare & Monti | tomatoes, mozzarella, baby shrimp, porcini mushrooms, olive oil, parsley
A closer look.
Troisi | white pizza with sausage, rapini and olive oil
Again, great, compelling crust. I also really appreciated the bitterness of the rapini, which was tender without being mushy. But the sausage was a bit dried out and somewhat devoid of flavor.
Troisi | white pizza with sausage, rapini and olive oil
A closer look. Crust-wise, it really doesn't get much better than this.
Troisi | white pizza with sausage, rapini and olive oil
Side view. A fairly even crumb.
I really like the all-Italian beer list. On my first visit, we shared a large format Manabrea 'Top Restaurant' Double Malt that was really a nice match for the food. At lunch I had a 330ml Manabrea Ambrata that I also liked, but not quite as much. It had very up front concord grape and honey notes that I found somewhat distracting but the finish was nice and its maltiness matched up well with the pizza dough. There are some other offerings that also look interesting and I hope to try them in the future.
It's hard to say after just 2 visits how variable Nella's is going to be over the long haul. My first meal there was the best Napoletana-style pizza I've ever had. Saturday's lunch was still very good but nowhere near the transcendent level of the dinner. At that dinner, even a Nutella dessert pizza that was sent out for us by the kitchen was astonishing. When we saw it on the menu, we chuckled. After it arrived, we ate the whole thing. Maybe lunch isn't as good a time to go as dinner is. Maybe it was just a different day. I really don't know. I do know that I'll be back. That is for sure but it won't be with the unbridled enthusiasm I felt after my first meal here.
=R=
By protecting others, you save yourself. If you only think of yourself, you'll only destroy yourself. --Kambei Shimada
Every human interaction is an opportunity for disappointment --RS
There's a horse loose in a hospital --JM
That don't impress me much --Shania Twain