Ill chime in on this old thread. We moved to LaSalle County 2 years ago after 30+ years in Naperville, and have tried most of the spots mentioned above, and I will add some new ones as well that are worthy of a visit for folks coming out to Starved Rock, or visiting other spots out here. The food in LaSalle County is decent, lots of fried chicken, pork tenderloin sandwiches, supper clubs, and the best cajun restaurant in Illinois. Here are my picks.
Bartley's Supper Club
414 1st Street
LaSalle Illinois
Enjoyable small supper club with a nice bar, and friendly owner who works the bar and dining room. I have enjoyed steaks, and everything I have had here.
Hank's Farm
2973 N. Route 71
Ottawa, IL.
Some of the better fried chicken around, we have also tried the pasta dishes here, and suprisingly a crab claw appetizer that was good. Good home cooking with a nice salad bar.
Casa Mia
219 18th Avenue
Naplate, IL.
Italian food, above average veal, and chicken dishes as well as some crab, steak, scallop, & shrimp entrees. Nice cozy spot with a small bar.
Uptown Grill
601 1st Street
LaSalle, IL.
I do not like the Uptown very much, we have had maybe 4 meals there, and they seem to be pushing the limits of what their kitchen staff can accomplish. The bar is expensive, $11 shots of Cazadores tequilla... Not a place I recommend to anyone.
Rockwell Inn
2400 W. Route 6
Morris, IL.
Nice restaurant, I prefer lunch here over dinner, very good rueben, and a very good pork tenderloin sandwich. The Bar area is very nice, and the drinks are cheap.
Mariachi's
1911 Ottawa Ave
Naplate, IL.
An above average Mexican restaurant for the area. Not Amanacer Tapatio, but who is. For a good burrito, some guacamole, and a large selection of cheap tequilla this is the place I go.
Cajun Connection
897 E. Hwy 6
Utica, IL.
The best restaurant in the area, and the best cajun food I have found anywhere around Chicago. The gumbo is top notch as well as the jambalaya, etouffe, fried corn, and everything else I have tried. The chef/owner is on site every day, and crawfish boils are had on occasion when he can get the fresh product on his trips down to Louisiana when he picks up supllies.
Cherry Supper Club
110 N. Main
Cherry, IL.
One of my favorite places to go, located in the small town of Cherry, just west of Peru, the Cherry Supper Club has never disappointed. We have gone maybe 15 times, and enjoy the fried chicken, the fish, the ribs, and everything on the menu. Every meal comes with salad bar, and soup, & the the hash brown potatoes are some of the best I have had. There are menu specials every night, and we can miost nights get out of there for under $30 including shots at the bar, a few Budweisers, and alot of hearty food.
None of the above are fine dining, but good locally owned places that give you good food for a good price. We still need to "escape" almost weekly into the city or suburbs to find some food that isnt well represented out here(chinese, deli, bbq, top notch steakhouses, & seafood), but I wouldnt live anywhere else.
Enjoy.