I had a stunning meal at l2o last night as the capstone of a whirlwind dining tour of the windy city. Kirkley's food was on point, the service was formal yet warm and entirely befitting of a place aiming to regain some lost Michelin stars. Many complaints that have been repeated over this thread and the last have been resolved or rendered irrelevant. Managed to snap a few photos, thought I would share those along with some brief comments on the menu(s). If I rave, stop me, but this was a damned fine meal.
We had e-mailed shortly after making reservations a month ago to see if we would be able to do some combination of the regular tasting and their luxury tasting menu. A prompt response from the restaurant informed us that Chef Kirkley would be delighted to prepare a 12-14 course chef's tasting, to which we agreed. Surprisingly, we were not only served 12 courses, but many of my dining companions dishes were completely different than mine (not just different riffs on the same ingredient). These also seemed to be plated for easy sharing between us (though I can't be sure there was any difference from normal presentations).
Before starting, I ordered the L2o sazerac, mixed tableside. It was my favorite rendition ever of my all-time favorite cocktail. The simple syrup was made from sugar that had been smoked with discarded bourbon barrels, and after the meal we found the recipe for the cocktail in an envelope with our menus. My dining companion had the ginger mint julep and found it quite enjoyable. I opted for the wine pairing - I won't comment further on that except to say the wines selected were all phenomenal, paired well with the food . Onto the menu:
Fruits de MerSmall canapes of halved, balled melon split and filled. One was a cantaloupe filled with foie gras, another was honey melon with oyster, and I can't remember the third.
Mussel Tartelette, Garlic LemonThe amuse proper was a very thin, airy crisp topped with a luscious green mousse that exploded with briny mussel flavor. I didn't notice garlic or lemon, ocean flavor was dominant. A great opening to the seafood focused meal. .
Bread service started, which as many have noted is top-notch. At this point, the restaurant's wine director approached our table and asked us to join him for a moment, and we were led back in the lobby of the hotel. Typically, I'm not used to getting kicked out of a restaurant before the first course, but instead we were brought through a back door into the kitchen.

After a full tour, including seeing some of the beautiful whole fish they receive daily, an impressive caviar drawer, and what we were told is the largest selection of Dom Perignon vintages in the Chicago-area, we returned to our seats to begin the meal proper.
Ahi Tuna Tartare, Avocado, Tomato, Caviar Cotes du Rhone Rose, Alain Jaume & Fils, "Reserve Grand Veneur," 2011, while my companion was served
Kona Kampachi, Watermelon, White Soy, Yuzu-Pistachio Emulsion
The tomato was present in the tomato-water gel at the bottom of the plate, which was to my palate somewhat extraneous. The tartare was very fresh and well seasoned. In my companions dish, the watermelon was compressed with the white soy. Coincidentally, the last bite we had before this meal was yuzu-pistachio macarons at Yusho.
Maryland Blue Crab en Gelee, Basil, Fennel Cream Soave Classico, Gini, "Contrada Salverenza," 2006, while my companion had
Smoked Salmon, Artichoke, Pumpernickel, Smoked Creme Fraiche, Beet
The crab was my least favorite dish of the evening. Too many soft textures and flavors that just did not gel. However, my companions dish was an architectural masterpiece of plating design that was a spot on rendition of a classic flavor combination. It was also quite large, with a substantial portion of (very smoky) salmon.
Scallop, Foie Gras, Hon-Shimeji, Argan Oil Savennieres, Domaine des Baumard, 2008A circle of foie gras mousse topped with a small dice of raw scallops, tiny pickled hon-shimeji mushrooms, and an even tinier brunoise of a sherry vinaigrette gelee. The scallops, mushrooms, and vinaigrette were an inspired raw combination that I could have eaten a bowl of. The richness of the (delicious) foie wasn't really cut well from the mildly acidic mushrooms and the small amount of vinaigrette and struck a discordant note; I wound up scraping the scallops off the top halfway through to eat by themselves and eating the rest of the mousse on bread.
Turbot, Cepe, Champagne, Brown Butter, Parlsey Chablis, 1er Cru, Vaillons, Thierry Laffay, 2009Thick pieces of poached turbot, stuffed with porcini mushrooms and floating in a rich, yet thin champagne/brown butter sauce. This course was an umami bomb. Very good. My only beef may be that the turbot was quite large but it seems silly to look a gift horse in the mouth.
Agnolotti, Artichoke, Ricotta, Clarified Barigoule Rare Wine Company, Savannah Verdelho, Special Reserve Madeira while my companion was served
Dumpling, Loup de Mer, Broccoli, Scallop Sauce
The agnolotti were stuffed with carrot, celery, and ricotta, topped with a brunoise of the same vegetables and crispy artichoke quarters in an incredibly strong consomme that I believe was made from beef and duck stock. Kirkley has a way with pasta, this was well put together and had a wonderful wine pairing that bypassed the artichokes and pasta to focus solely on bringing out the richness of the stock. A gamble that worked. I didn't get to try the dumpling but my companion said it was one of his favorites.
Bouillabaisse, Daurade, Loup de Mer, Clams, Tomato, Fennel Hermitage, J.L. Chave, 2000 while my companion was served
Rouget Barbet, Pea Risotto, Saffron, Lavender
Picture is of the bouillabaisse. Menu says clams but it was actually a mussel. The fish in this dish were the standout - all were cooked to
perfection, meltingly tender with shatteringly crisp skin. The broth was almost redundant, as was the crisp topped with a saffron mayo. The tomato confit was nice, fennel was very thinly sliced and raw underneath the fish.
I wish we had a picture of the rouget barbet; this dish was an absolute stunner and maybe the best we tried this evening. Neither of us had tried the fish before, it was rich and oily with a texture (and taste) somewhat akin to king crab. I always worry when I see lavender foams anywhere, but this one had a thicker mouthfeel with just the subtlest hint of floral notes.
Butter Poached Lobster, Cepess, Potato, Clams, Hollandaise de Mer Saint Clair, Pinot Noir, Doctor's Creek, Marlborough, 2007I am not a fan of lobster. Don't hate it, but if given nine other protein options at random, there's a good chance I'd rank lobster tenth in preference. This, however, was rich and wonderful. I love when chefs pull out the nods toward levity and throw down a certifiable gluttonous dish. Huge chunks of lobster perched over a square of potato that had been stuffed with porcini mousse, poached, and then grilled. Topped table-side with a (massive amount) of hollandaise cut with clam juice, all of which was promptly soaked up by that wonderful bread.
28-Day Dry Aged Ribeye, Lobster, Spring Onion, Brioche, Civet Chateau Sociando-Mallet Haut-Medoc, 1995 while my companion received
Pigeon Breast, Foie Gras, Turnip, Apicius, Sweet Potato

After the huge amount of lobster on the prior course, I was surprised to see even more. This dish was a very solid take on surf-and-turf, with delicious steak and the aforementioned cephalopod alternating and perched atop a brioche toast. Nothing offensive about this but nothing really groundbreaking. My companions dish was my favorite non-seafood course of the evening. Foie gras torchon meat glued to perfectly cooked, rare squab breast and what I seem to recall was an apricot sauce. I didn't get to try the sweet potato component, as it's my companions favorite food, but he raved about it on the way home.
Palate cleanser was a lemon ice topped with spearmint granita. Lemon and mint are my all time favorite flavors so this was great.
Lemon Tart, Rhubarb, Basil Malaga, Jorge Ordonez & Co., #2, 2010,
Fromage Blanc, Calvados Caramel, Apples,
Praline Souffle, Hazelnut Anglaise
We each received our own dessert plus the souffle to share. These were all excellent. My tart was made from the most fragile, ethereal dough; I'm not sure how they were able to pipe in the lemon mousse without shattering it. The souffle was textbook. I didn't taste my companions dessert but he loved it.
Petits fours
Macarons (cherry-chocolate, yuzu, pistachio) and a canele (devoured before pic was taken). I could have eaten a bucket of these.
There had been a dearth of recent reports on L2o from this site and others, and I feared making my reservation that it might not live up to the price tag, but we both walked out pleasantly stunned. 18 different courses, all substantial and only one real miss and many huge hits. Combined with the bread service, flawless pastries, and excellent service, particularly from the wine and beverage staff - I will certainly return. Though I make this comparison based on the restaurants similar aspirations (Michelin and critically speaking) and not to ruffle feathers, I had two meals at Alinea in the past year, and our meal last night at L2o rivaled both of those. Phew, there's my first trip report! Some of you make this look easy.