Part Three: Hackney and F. Cooke
Canal, Towpath Narrow Boats and Condos #2 by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Canal boat dwellers take some of the credit for what many consider the resurgence of the borough of Hackney, once known as a crime-ridden part of London. The area is newly attractive to a class of young Londoners depicted as "creative" - or at least interested in biking, beards and organic produce. These depictions may be well-founded. When I visited in October, the Lock 7 Cycle Café and the Hackney Cycle Shop seemed to be thriving.
Lock 7 Cycle Cafe, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Hackney Cycle Shop by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Slow Foodists have installed themselves at one end of Haggerston Park, with Hackney City Farm's petting zoo, “Agriturismo” Italian food and film nights, and celebrations for the kids, such as "National Apple Day."
Hackney City Farm, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Even the local graffiti suggests the hand of a natural foods-oriented parent.
Graffiti, Hackney, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Some of the comparatively privileged newcomers live cheaply and flexibly on narrow boats by committing to changing moorings regularly. Security concerns related to the 2012 Olympics led to
claims of discrimination against boat residents without permanent moorings. One resident, for instance, reported having to register as “homeless” when seeking medical care. This bit of graffiti near the Cat and Mutton Bridge seems to reflect Olympics-related controversies:
Olympic Protest Graffiti, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Newcomers to Hackney are seen as the source of difficulties associated with gentrification, including the steep rise in prices for former council flats and the disappearance of affordable shops in favor of expensive artisanal bakeries and trendy café reboots of old pubs. Indeed, the Cat and Mutton Pub near Broadway Market was hopping on the afternoon when I visited,
Hackney Corner by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
but the doner kebab shop was shuttered.
Kebab House Sign, Hackney by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Whatever the losses to gentrification, at least one vestige of Hackney’s working class heritage remains: F. Cooke, Live Eel Importer. This shop dates from 1900. It is run by the Cooke family to this day.
F. Cooke, Live Eel Importer, Hackney, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
According to
British food blogger Neil Buttery and other sources, Frederick Cooke’s original eel, pie and mash establishment opened in Clerkenwell in 1862. It was one of many such shops that took the pie trade away from street vendors and relocated it to comparatively comfortable, pleasing, and hygienic tiled interiors. F. Cooke's interior remains as it was in Victorian times, furnished with marble tables and wooden benches. Sawdust on the floor originally served to corral eel bones spat out by patrons. Concessions to modernity consist of Pepsi signs and a worn photograph of Princess Diana:
F. Cooke Interior, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
F. Cooke Interior by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The shop is one of about 80 Pie-'n-Mash shops that remain in Britain today. What is not clear is how many of these shops still serve eels,
“the poor man’s delicacy”. Even as the number of London's eel, pie and mash houses expanded during the late 19th century, a filling of meat and onions was creeping into the eel pies, and then replacing eel altogether. It appears that eel pie was a bargain option (think dollar menu ca. 1880), with meat pies being more expensive. During WWII, however, eels served as a cheap local source of protein. This may have led to their postwar return as London soul food.
Eels have probably been fished in England's rivers since well before
King Henry I died in 1135 after a repast of "lampreys". Sources differ on whether eels survived in the polluted waters of the Thames during Victorian times, however, Londoners’ appetites for eel seem to have outstripped the supply, and eels began to be imported from Holland. Currently, according to Buttery, eels are endangered, although it is legal to fish for them. The principal threat to the eel population appears to be man-made barriers obstructing the natural migration patterns of these
catadromous fish.
Ethical fishing practices have been instituted to address the problem by relocating some elvers upstream to mature, and selling others to commercial fish farms. Ron’s Eel and Shell Fish (sic) advertises its wares over Regent's Canal:
Ron's Eel and Shell Fish - Hoxton St. Market by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Although Ron may be local, it’s likely that his eels come from Ireland or The Netherlands. I found these (smoked at left and skinned at right) at Fortnum & Mason, London:
Eels at Fortnum & Mason by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Although F. Cooke remains in its original form, it was rather deserted on the day I visited. Both of the other diners in the shop were eating meat pies and mash, hold the “liquor”- a parsley-colored gravy with a base of eel stewing liquid.
Serving up the Eels, F. Cooke, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
From the small number of eel filets in the stewpot, I wondered whether demand for eels had subsided significantly. Tasting the stewed eels, I found it difficult to appreciate their appeal.
Boiled Eels in Parsley Sauce, F. Cooke by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Normally, I enjoy eel – whether as
unagi or
matelote, however, this dish was challenging in ways I did not anticipate. Let’s take a closer look:
Eels in Parsley Sauce by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Notice the grey skin of the eel section. This was slimy and unpleasantly oily, which would not have been a problem had it not clung tenaciously to the flesh. I found the white flesh itself no more approachable, since a gummy clear membrane lining the darker grey skin clung to the meat and imparted the same unpleasant taste. The pretty green “liquor” tasted of starches and not much else - certainly nothing herbal - and its effect was to add bland and gooey onto bland and gooey. Clearly, I missed out on the vinegar and chili pepper, which I later learned was to be sprinkled on the dish. This might have offset the muddy, oily taste of the eel and the slimy mouthfeel of the entire dish. Considering the textural issues with the fish itself, I was very glad I had not opted for the jellied eels. I found myself wondering if eels, like lutefisk, are palatable only with mashed potato. A crust might help, but eel pies seem to have been replaced by meat pies on Cooke’s menu, and, I suspect, the menus of most eel, pie and mash shops that survive. All in all, I'm glad I tried the stewed eels, but, as with Fall River's chow mein sandwich, I will not be going back for seconds.
Menu - F. Cooke, London by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Truth be told, I approached the eel experience with a Fear Factor mentality shared by at least some who visit F. Cooke, for whom this picture is no doubt thrilling in its counter-phobic intensity:
Fear Factor, London Edition by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Puzzled at the iconic status of eel in London, I decided to do some digging around. Happily, I ran across a very charming primary source in
pie-and-mash.com, a site dedicated to gathering memories of the once ubiquitous eel, pie and mash shops. A close reading of these accounts brought to life the experience of visiting such shops in the old days. In addition to being a restaurants, the eel houses were fish markets opening onto the streets, selling eels for home consumption:
“While Mum queued for our lunch my brother and I would stand outside in our grey shorts (and navy duffel coats in winter), mesmerised by the deft art of the eel man on the stall in the street. We would watch the silvery grey eels sliding lugubriously around the ice blocks in their battered steel trays. Housewives would point at the eel they wanted "for hubbie's tea" and the eel man would seize the creature and whack it down on his bloodied wooden block. Then, with a knife that seemed the size of a broadsword to our tiny eyes, he would chop off the head, slit down the still writhing length of its belly and drag it under the back of the knife to gut it. Then chop, chop, chop into sections, wrapped in newspaper, weighed and sold.”For children, part of the appeal was in the spectacle of eel butchery. One poster (again,on the website pie-and-mash.com) reports a “first memory” of eels moving after they were cut up, just as
Mrs. Beeton cautioned: “TENACITY OF LIFE IN THE EEL - There is no fish so tenacious of life as this. After it is skinned and cut in pieces, the parts will continue to move for a considerable time, and no fish will live so long out of water.”
Many who contributed to the pie-and-mash website reminisced with the kind of visual detail that only flashbulb memory can summon:
" I can remember Manze's of the fifties and early sixties as if it were yesterday: heavy white marble tables, sitting on wooden forms with high wooden backs that formed a cosy booth. Black, green and white tiles. The smell made my mouth water. The knives, forks and spoons were enormous post-war utility aluminium implements that we could just about get our hands around. No turning the pie over; it was splosh, splosh, splosh with the big pop bottle of vinegar with a nail hole in the cap, take care to select the salt shaker rather than the sugar (they were both in identical glass shakers with dull silver tops). Then admire the brown puddles sploshed in the green liquor and discolouring the mash that had been deftly wiped around the edge of the plate before getting to work on the dish.”This man’s account of eel pie (also from pie-and-mash.com) makes him sound like an LTH-er:
“I liked to cut around the edge of the pie crust, lift it off and drop it in the liquor top-down, then another quick splosh of vinegar in the pie and on the crust. First thing to be eaten was the crust, then the mash and then scoop forkfulls of the mince from the pie. I would be left with the soft, slippery, silver pie base that reminded me so much of the underbelly of a freshly caught trout. This was my favourite part. I would cut pieces of that base off and savour them, allowing each piece to melt in my mouth before chewing. Finally, I would scrape the last remaining vestiges of vinegered liquor from the plate with a spoon. It would be quite a few years before I would learn that there were other things that could bring me such ecstasy!”Whatever my reaction to the eels at F. Cooke, the dish is indelibly written in the life narratives of East Enders. (Again, from pie-and-mash.com):
“My Mum (who, as a little girl in the thirties, was brought up on pie and mash at M. Manze's in Chapel Street Market) had moved to Walthamstow and tells me that during her pregnancy she had those ‘uncontrollable cravings’ that pregnant women have. Her craving was for pie, mash and liquor. “Wouldn’t you know that this man claims his first taste of eel was taken seated on his mother’s knee? Many of the memories shared In these accounts recall an eel house as the site of a first restaurant experience with beloved grandparents, a snack shared with schoolmates, or a rare family outing. The eel houses offered a meal accessible to anyone, even in hard times, if only as a plate of "mash and liquor" - potatoes and the cooking liquid from the eels, studded with parsley and sprinkled with free vinegar.
Attachment to a specific pie shop comes through in these accounts, along with claims of objective superiority that echo Pizza Preference Theory. As a repository of early memories, the eel house becomes a portal to the past and a vehicle for expressing a host of emotions, including love, pride, nostalgia, and even grief. Is it any wonder that one woman writes of her present-day dreams of eating eel pie, mash and liquor with her father at the eel house of her youth?
This brings me around to reflecting on the place of honor held by eel pie in the celebration of Queen Elizabeth’s Diamond Jubilee, referenced in
this thread. The Wall Street Journal seems to have accepted at face value
Gloucester's claim to ownership of this dish, which, though grounded in history (and the current survival of eels in the River Servern), does not acknowledge the
tradition of eel cookery tied to London's East End, as well as areas of Essex and Kent. The significance of eel pie to Londoners of the Queen’s generation may lie in the fact that eels served as a balm for the privations of rationing during and after World War II. I'm guessing that Her Majesty ate more than the occasional eel pie - if only for solidarity's sake - during her youth in wartime London. And - who knows? -perhaps some of her kids made rebellious incognito visits to
Eel Pie Island back in the 60's.
This photograph, displayed in the front window of F. Cooke under the Union Jack, shows a scene at F. Cooke as it might have looked to the young Queen Elizabeth.
Customers Lined up for Eels, F. Cooke (1940's?) by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
F. Cooke
9 Broadway Market
London, E8 4PH
Tel 020 7254 6458
Man : I can't understand how a poet like you can eat that stuff.
T. S. Eliot: Ah, but you're not a poet.