Reviewing a list of savory bites from 2007 (far below), there have been some major changes, although the polestars (all outside of Oak Park proper) are still shining bright. Here would be my current recommendations.
Grocers / Provisioners:Tony's Finer Foods (25th and Harlem, North Riverside)
Familia Foods (7065 Cermak, Berwyn)
Wettstein Meats (Farmers Market summer, Buzz Cafe winter, Oak Park)
Trader Joe's (Harlem just north of Lake, Oak Park)
Whole Foods (Harlem and Lake, River Forest)
Billy's (Madison/Ridgeland, Oak Park, cheapest limes, salt pork, greens, and avocados)
House Red (on Madison in Forest Park, wines and Vosges chocolates)
Freddy's (Italian, see below)
Riviera (Italian, see below)
Dining in Oak Park Proper:Marion Street Cheese Market (good food, goofy service, also a grocer)
Winberie (not a board favorite, has been good for me lately, steak sandwich and Caesar)
Maya del Sol (brunch much better than dinner, homemade chorizo, great patio)
Poor Phil's (oyster shooters and muffaletta, improving beer list)
Hemmingway's Bistro (particularly the Moroccan dishes, forgive the decor)
Khyber Pass (northern Indian with some pan-Indo-Pak, ditch the buffet)
Trattoria 225 (wood-fired pork and veggies, pasta weaker)
The Pasta Shoppe (wood-fired pizzas, pastas can be bland, outdoor dining)
Fuego Loco (really nice service, stick with specials and carne caliente, faux-Mex)
Papaspiros (excellent loukaniko, go small plates over entrees)
Oak Park Bakery (donuts, German Chocolate Coffee Cake)
Taste of Brazil (empanadas and coffee, feijoada on weekends)
Five Guys (burgers and fresh-cut fries)
The Onion Roll (breakfast with NY Bagel and Bialy goods)
Dining in bordering towns:Bodhi Thai (creative pan-Thai, limited off-menu northern Thai, Berwyn)
Yum Thai (American pan-Thai, extensive secret menu Thai, Forest Park)
Xni-Pec (Yucateco Mexican, Cicero)
Freddy's (southern Italian, Cicero)
Klas (Czech, Cicero)
Depot American Diner (American, Chicago [Austin])
Cafe Laguradia West (Cuban, Chicago [North Avenue])
Johnny's Beef (Elmwood Park)
Gaetano's (auteur Italian/Sicilian, Forest Park)
Paciugo (Gelato, Forest Park)
Don Alfredo Carnitas (Mexican, Maywood)
La Lupita (Mexican, Berwyn)
Tamale Hut Cafe (Guerrero/Oaxacan Mexican, North Riverside)
Mama Susi (Turano Bakeshop, Berwyn)
MacArthur's (Soul Food, Chicago)
Dining within another 7 minutes of bordering towns on side streets:The Riviera (southern Italian sandwiches and grocer, N)
The Brown Sack (auteur American comfort food, NE)
Cemitas Puebla (Pueblo Mexican, NE)
Emilio's Tapas (southern Iberian, W)
The Epicurean Hungarian (Hungarian, W)
Priscilla's (Soul Food, W)
Edelweiss (German, N)
Sol de Mexico (auteur Mexican, NE)
Non-culinary but awesome people/resources:Two Fish (lighting, artglass, and gifts, Forest Park)
Schauer Hardware (Forest Park)
Emil's Barber Shop (Oak Park)
Thiesse Plumbing (Forest Park)
I'll come back and link as many of these as I can (use search function for now).
Of the below, Cafe le Coq and Nola's Cup have closed.
I do not currently recommend:Briejo (oversalted)
Wishbone (overgreasy)
Avenue Alehouse (insipid)
JTs (unprocurable)
La Majada (reconstituted)
Nuevo Rebozo (exorbitant)
Robinson's (flavorless)
Mama Thai (vapid)
King and I (careless)
Amarind (supercilious)
Luo's Peking House (Havishamesque)
Szechwan Beijing (deceased)
Penny's Noodles (pococurante)
Erik's (spurious)
Parky's (haggard)
New Pot (canned)
Grape Leaves (languid)
Turco's (mercenary)
Happy dining!
Ancient History wrote:DH et al:
Here are some other hopes for our native territory -
- Beignets and coffee at Nola's Cup. Their muffaletta is still quite weak but man can they do deep fried, and are finally coming up to speed on some other entrees (pretty decent gumbo, and a nice pork shoulder special).
- the Pilsen specials menu at Fuego Loco. They had it on May 5th and again over Memorial Day. Shockingly, someone at this yuppified Tex-Mex marg-joint finally hired a cook with some pride, as we had excellent cumin-lamb tacos, ceviche, and pulled roast chicken with three kinds of hot sauteed peppers. Their salsas are improving as well along with the service. The tasty 'carne caliente' with all of the sauteed peppers and garlic butter, does strongly remind me of something I had in Playa del Carmen - admittedly not the most traditional area in the country - but order it with the tortillas separate or you'll be dripping.
- Moroccan plates du jour at Hemmingway's Bistro. I had a marvelous lamb with home-made couscous pearls and preserved lemon in April, and have noticed other lemon and harissa-laced specials of late.
- Saltimbocca at the Pasta Shoppe - you must admit it's a very pretty room with all of the hardwood, but I'll understand if the very poor overcooked chicken entrees have disappointed in the past. Their fresh pastas are usually solid, and I've had a few above average items recently, including a nice saltimbocca and a very spicy arrabiata.
Otherwise, yes, it's fairly dismal. I never want to go to the Avenue / Alehouse / Whatever again after their burgers and fries went from moist and tasty to frozen Sysco crud. Cafe le Coq did suck for a little while (gristly steak, oversalted cassoulet, no specials) but seems to be returning. Completely disenchanted with the cuisine at La Majada and the prices at Nuevo Rebozo, though Paco is affable and occasionally the pipian verde mole special or tortilla soup with frijoles negros can hit the spot. Winberie is just not there anymore, especially for brunch. They still make what I consider a good Caesar salad and an excellent Bloody Mary. Erik's has one reasonable sandwich to my mind - roast beef with french-fried onions on a croissant - but they have no good condiments to accompany (horseradish mayo, good Dijon mustard, any good barbecue sauce) and just about everything else there is dull beyond words. I always want to give Robison's BBQ another chance but have been affronted by surly or incompetent order takers and gloppy undercooked pork far too many times. Mama Thai makes me weep at the possibilities gone wrong (worst.beef.salad.evAr.)
My guilty pleasures that offer sustenance but not really hope are Carnitas crispy tacos from Chipotle, the 'thai ravioli' bowl from Penny's (lots of peanuts, roast pork, sweet chile oil, dumplings), and a very few dishes from Szechwan Beijing (sic), including the salt and pepper chicken and Mongolian beef (well-spiced, although the meat quality isn't uniform).
I have to remind myself that other places I frequent - Parky's, Amarind, Wishbone at Fitzgeralds, Johnnie's, Freddy's, La Piazza - are not actually in Oak Park even though you could hit most of them with a 3-wood from our borders. I have some hopes for Harrison Street (Buzz and the new place). Perhaps we can do a tour of the surrounding highlights sometime soon.