Dali: Bai Arts, Rice Cakes, Milk Fans and Babas
Bai Woman on Lake Erhai, Yunnan by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The Bai people, literally, the “White” people, number 2 million individuals living mostly in the area around Dali, Yunnan, near Er Lake (Chinese: 洱海, Erhai). The Bai revere the color white, believing it to represent dignity, a tradition that is reflected in their clothing and their architecture. The connection to Lake Er and its nearby rivers means a steady supply of fish for the Bai table.
We were fortunate to stay in the Yang Jia Yuan, a traditional Bai stone courtyard complex that is home to the
Linden Centre of Xizhou, near Dali. (My chief source for the material on Bai culture is their
informative website.) Restored by the
Linden family in a partnership with Chinese cultural authorities, the Yang Jia Yuan was historically the home of the Yang family. The home has three formal courtyards and three “sky wells” – paved terraces with water wells - as well as secondary courtyards. The Linden Centre is set in a village among fields that yield canola in the early summer and rice in the late fall.
Bai Farmer in Canola Field, Dali, Yunnan by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Not surprisingly, Bai homes are painted white with a lime-based paint. One feature of Bai architecture is the “picture wall.” The use of white paint on the picture wall serves a practical purpose as well as an aesthetic one: to reflect light and heat into the central courtyard. Typical decoration includes slabs of white marble whose veins suggest landscape scenes, such as this one from the Yang Jia Yuan:
Picture Wall, Yang Jia Yuan, Xizhou by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The entrances of Bai homes also receive special attention; they signal the status of the family through artwork that communicates themes of harmony and prosperity. Here, a tiled roof with curved ends and carved wooden eaves sit above a painting depicting two red-breasted birds, one above the other on a branch. Could the two birds represent the successful partnership of a father and son?
Carved Eaves, Yang Jia Yuan, Xizhou by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The interiors of traditional homes feature two-story galleries. Rooms brightened by windows face outward toward the courtyard. Here is a view of the walkway outside our room in the Yang Jia Yuan:
Gallery, Linden Centre, Xizhou by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
According to the Linden Centre website, "The rooms of honor, facing the picture wall, are all entered via six carved wood door panels. These panels, which often included patterns of flowers, birds and local characters, were often the source of greatest pride for the Bai owner. The Linden Centre’s door panels have all survived unscathed due to the fact that the military was based in the complex; thankfully our building was off-limits to vandals, thieves, and Red Guards."
Fabric arts, particularly batik dyeing and embroidery are a prominent tradition among the Bai. This collection of mostly antique embroidery was on display at the Linden Centre, where support of traditional crafts is part of the mission of the enterprise:
Carpet of Bai Embroidery by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Bai Embroidery by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Embroidery is also a feature of everyday clothing. Most younger Bai women wear a crown embroidered with camelias. The crown's crescent shape represents a flower in the wind and the moon on a snowy evening. A white fringe tops the crown and a tail of white trails down the back.
Embroidering in Yunnan by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Older Bai women seem to favor what I am going to call the "church hat," a wide-brimmed hat woven of fine straw. This is worn on top of a scarf that has a trailing white tail. Some older women also wear a blue or purple Communist-era cap, particularly while at work. Both styles are seen on the women embroidering in this photograph:
Bai Women Embroidering by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Traditional ways persist, but they seem only to feed the appetite for embroidered fabrics, here being made by machine:
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The Bai are also known for their metalwork. Hotpots and tea kettles seem to be the most popular items.
Hotpots, Lijiang Market by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Hotpots, Lijiang Market by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Silver craft is also practiced. Here is a selection of teapots from a shop in Lijiang:
Silver Shop, Lijiang by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Three Bai Foods: Er Kuai, Dengshuan Rushan, and Xizhou BabaThe best known Bai specialties seem to arise out of Bai craftsmanship and - perhaps - an affinity for white things. The first of these is Er Kuai 饵块 (pinyin ěrkuài) a highly refined and compressed rice cake.
Er Kuai (Rice Cakes) by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
There's certainly an artisanal quality to the rice cake maker's tools:
Noodle Maker's Tools by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Noodle Maker's Shop with Necessities by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
This is, however, a shop doing some high volume production.
Flour for Noodles by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
We watched the noodle makers at work. The first step involves putting the rice flour into a machine to mix the dough.
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Dough is then extracted, kneaded, weighed and cut. I'd say that still qualifies as handmade.
Making Rice Cakes by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
They made some really beautiful noodles, too.
Rice Noodles, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Dengchuan Rushan 邓川乳扇, or Dengchuan Milk Fan really had me stumped. We saw this basket in the Dali Market. To me, its uniformity and shine made me think I was looking at a basket of rolled plastic bags, ready to be grasped by their ends and deployed as containers. Not so. This was an example of a Bai cows' milk cheese made in Dengshuan, a town at the north end of Lake Er.
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
In fact, we had already sampled this cheese - deep fried - while visiting Kunming:
Fried Dengshuan Cheese by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
What was not clear was how and why the cheese is formed in this unusual fashion. I was told that the thinness and dryness of the Dengshuan cheese allows it to puff up when fried. Fair enough, but what is the method that stretches it? I only yesterdat discovered the answer to my question - through the magic of the internet, of course. A woman who took one of the excursions offered by the Linden Centre blogged about it
here. It is definitely worth opening the link to see the photos of the traditional way of stretching and rolling the cheese over sticks.
I also found an account of making Dengshuan milk fan on
this website:
"Although tasteful, milk fan is not complicated to make. The making process is: first ferment the milk into acidophilus milk and heat it in a boiler to a temperature of 70 to 80 degrees Celsius; then add some fresh milk and stir it with a wooden spoon. The acidophilus milk and the fresh milk flocculate and then agglomerate. Take the agglomerate out, knead it and then pull it into a thin piece that is about 20 centimeters long and 8 centimeters wide. Last, pull the two ends of the piece a little thinner and longer, and dry it with the two ends rolled around two slender bamboo rods. The distance between the two rods is about 16 to 17 centimeters and there can be more than 10 milks fan drying on them. After drying, the two-layer milk fans can be loosened and then taken off . . . Milk fans can be stored for a long time and are portable. The Bai people often entertain their guests with a dish prepared with milk fans, or give it to people as presents."
Milk fan is "not complicated to make" you say? I say milk fan pulling makes knitting (a skill I will never, ever, ever master) look like a cinch.
The same website also writes about ways that milk fans are prepared:
"Cook eggs with fresh milk and put some milk fans and rock candy, and then you have what is called "fresh milk, egg, rock candy, milk fans." If you cook eggs with brown sugar and milk fans, you will have milk fan poached eggs. You can also cook other dishes with milk fans, such as "fried milk fan chips," "braised sanxian (three kinds of fresh food) milk fans," "deep-fried milk fans," and "steamed stuffed bun with milk fan inside," and many others. To conclude, milk fans are sweet when eaten raw, fragrant and spicy when fried, soft and tasteful when cooked, refreshing when steamed, and excessively aromatic when baked with some salt. Whichever cooking method you take, milk fans are always palatable and have a strong aftertaste."
I would agree that milk fans are "fragrant and spicy when fried," as they have some of the nutty, salty dry quality of a Manchego or a Parmagiana. They are not as crunchy as a Cheetoh, being firmer, with more pull when you bite down. I would have enjoyed trying some of the other milk fan dishes, though I cannot imagine what the texture of a milk-egg-rock candy dish might be. We did find some support for the notion that this is a popular dish, as rock candy was available by the slab in Dali's central market, along with palm sugar.
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Palm Sugar, Dali Market by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Xizhou Baba 喜洲: Photos from Dali Market
The town of Xizhou is known for baba, a stuffed bread baked in the open air in charcoal ovens. Eaten as a snack, this bread is sold on the streets of Xizhou, where a group of bakers vie for customers. These photos were taken at the Dali Morning Market. The baking tradition reportedly goes back eight centuries, and it is easy to imagine that the ovens themselves go back just about as far, though the electric fans that fan them appear to have replace earlier methods.
Street Oven, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Street Oven with Fan, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The baba's wheat flour dough is made with both yeast and baking powder and a bit of salt. In a well-floured table with high sides made specially for forming breads, risen dough is slathered with lard. It is then rolled, cut, and formed into a circles about 6 inches across. For the savory baba, chopped spring onion is added, and the dough is rolled again. Chopped pork is added and the dough is rolled yet again, slashed, and pressed into a circle. Here is a baba baker at work in the Dali Market. At her right on the work table are sweet baba fillings of red bean paste and sesame paste.
Adding Spring Onion to Xizhou Baba, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Putting Baba into Oven by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Prepared Baba, Ready to Bake by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
The bottom surface of the oven pan is oiled, and then the baker eases the prepared babas down onto the hot surface.
At this point, the care of the baba is turned over to the baker. He adjusts the lid and places hot charcoal on top of the lid. He deploys the fan to keep the coals at the right temperature.
Street Oven, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Midway through baking, the bread is turned and anointed with oil. Some sources say that the traditional recipe involves sesame oil, but I think in this case, the oil used was canola oil.
Anointing the Bread by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Taking Baba from Oven, Dali by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Baker Removing Baba from Oven by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Xizhou Baba, Dali, Yunnan by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Baker Cutting Xizhou Baba by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
These babas (both sweet and savory) rank among the best things I have ever eaten. Flaky and rich, with all the best properties of pastry, bread and pizza combined. I hope the
recipe I found (from Chef Yang of the Linden Center, written in English and adapted by Janice Thomas of Ellison Bay, Wisconsin can at least approximate the real thing. For the oven, I'll ask here for your suggestions.
One more photo of those babas. Because you can't have too much of a good thing!
Untitled by
Josephine2004, on Flickr
Man : I can't understand how a poet like you can eat that stuff.
T. S. Eliot: Ah, but you're not a poet.