My top three meals at Next have been El Bulli, Childhood and Paris (I've missed only the Hunt). While Childhood didn't necessarily deliver all of the magnificent flavors of the other two, it made up for that with genius creativity and a sense of nostalgia. Vegan is now another one of my favorite Next meals - not because I loved the food (I liked it a lot), but because I thought it was brilliantly concepted, beautifully presented, and mostly delicious. What I'm saying is that I love meat, eggs, butter, fish and cheese, and even when I eat vegetable-centric meals, damn if it's not because there's a perfectly cooked egg with an oozing yolk melting through the vegetables. So for me to leave a restaurant following a vegan meal, and more satisfied than after most other meals where I have plenty of meat, butter and eggs, that's quite a statement.
Let me start by apologizing for some of the less ideal photos - my position at the table, the lighting, and the rather fast and aggressive hands and hungry mouths at my table made my food photography habit quite the challenge. Allow me also to suggest the possibility of skipping my review if you will soon be dining at Next. As always, there are small surprises best experienced for the first time during the meal, and no question I will spoil some of that for you. You can always skip to the portion below my pictures to avoid these surprises.
We sat down to a table decorated with a vase of tree branches and a vase with floating lilies and a single, floating candle:


After a glass of Scharffenberger Brut Excellent, the vase of tree branches was immediately put to use with our first course, "kale bouquet." See, hiding in plain sight among the tree branches in the vase were long pieces of crisp sourdough flatbread. A large stone served as the communal plate, and was adorned with a blanket of intense charred avocado puree, along with kale shaped as flowers, and filled with avocado (and lime?) puree. You used the crisp flatbread to scoop up the puree. I would have preferred the flatbread to be a little more firmly crisp, but it was still quite good and the avocado puree silky smooth and delicious.
Kale BouquetWe were then presented with a rapid fire succession of small bites. There was a single bite of sprouted tempeh, which I did a poor job of both photographing and remembering.
Sprouted TempehThere was a beautiful and delicious frozen baked potato, served on a decorative metal piece similar to what I recall being used for the croquettas at the El Bulli menu. Like the perfect baked potato, there was crisp skin, a silky smooth filling, and chives. Simple, but one of my favorite bites of the evening.
Frozen Baked PotatoNext has always recognized not only that we eat with our eyes, but that we are also impressed with creative and fascinating ways to deliver food. This continued with the delivery of a large tree branch which held our next two bites.

Nori Dumpling and Earl Grey RambutanFirst on the branch, an ethereal yet rich nori dumpling that would cause any sushi lover to at least temporarily ignore his hatred of California rolls. There was also a hollowed-out rambutan, filled with a thick gel of rambutan juice and Earl Grey tea. It was a delicious small bite, though I don't recall in hindsight whether I actually tasted the tea accent.
One of my favorite bites of the evening was the slow roasted baby artichoke. I cannot recall ever having been served such a perfect roasted artichoke - the inner leaves perfectly edible, rich artichoke flavor puree lightly accented with lemon and a perfectly cooked heart. I was amazed how tender the artichoke was without being lifeless and limp . . . if only my picture captured the beauty.
Baby ArtichokeCould Next re-create the Paris duck course for Vegans? Not exactly, but they could certainly try in some respect:



The above was a fermented apple cider, with an apple cider vinegar quality and taste, prepared table-side. It was the beverage component to a plated apple sorbet, lichen (apparently an edible fungus that grows on apple trees), rose, cashews and cashew butter. I recall thinking that it was akin to a savory caramel apple, though perhaps more refreshing.
Fermented Apples and LichenThough the presence of the floating lilies never struck me as anything other than a table decoration, I really should have known better. Of course the water in the lily vase was really a vinegar solution. Of course the little leaves floating among the lilies were edible greens/herbs. (You may want to look just up above again for the lily vase/pond.) So after serving us edible roots of the lily plant, our server than garnished the lilies with some of the greens that had been floating in the vase. Surprisingly tasty, but even more impressive in terms of the surprising presentation. The drink component for this course was Duché de Longueville Cidre Bouché de Cru.
Lily PondFor some reason, in the Midwest it seems like we are always deprived of the wonderful, delicate flavors of white asparagus. So I was to be easily thrilled with the rice yogurt and white asparagus course. Underneath a crisp rice cracker lay white asparagus, rice yogurt, and small cubes of wine-poached pear. Though the asparagus, yogurt and pear component was spectacular, my rice cracker was so salty and close to being inedible. When my three dining companions looked at me as if I were crazy when I mentioned this, two of us exchanged portions of rice crackers, leaving my one friend gasping and grabbing for a drink of water because of the over-salting, and me smiling that I could taste all of the components together as had probably been intended. Someone in the kitchen must have had a shaky hand for a moment (or known who I was

) I will say that this was the only obvious flaw in the evening, yet this still was one of my few favorites.
Rice Yogurt and White AsparagusNext obviously recognized the challenges in serving a Vegan meal, and yet the need to fulfill expectations. And so surprises lurked at every turn. The course of salsifies with oyster and dandelion most certainly surprised. There was salsify served with what I believe was oyster leaf, and a classic mignonette sauce. There was also what I seem to recall being salsify, dandelion greens and a puree of dandelion greens (I think) that was delicious, but it was the flavor of a classic oyster presentation that impressed and thrilled me the most. This course was served with a 2009 Guy Breton Régnié (Beaujolais)
Salsifies with oyster and dandelionI was not quite as enamored with the Swiss chard and douchi - the Swiss chard leaf prepared tempura style, lightly greasy, served above a splatter of rhubarb, and spread very lightly with melted unsweetened chocolate. The leaf also served as the bread so to speak (or tostada as Next called it) for the mixture of fried douchi (fermented soybean), and more unsweetened chocolate. I seem to recall our server telling us this was meant to be similar to a molé. There was a lot going on here - sweet, sour, savory . . . but it just didn't come together so well for me, although it was beautifully plated.
Swiss chard and douchiI was reminded slightly of the delicious tofu dish at Sumi Robata Bar by the kombu atoll - seaweed, tofu skin, yuzu and soy sauces, if I recall correctly. It was light and delicious, with the kombu delivering a light sea flavor, thus playing the role of the vegan "roe" in this dish. It was as beautiful in appearance, served in a seashell-shaped dish. And it was accompanied by a great sake, Konteki Tears of Dawn Daiginjo from Kyoto.
Kombu AtollA lighter, almost comical moment, was when a server brought over the mushroom cart. I've seen my fair share of cheese carts, several beef and dessert carts too . . . but never a mushroom cart. I certainly don't envision this becoming a trend, so if you are insistent upon seeing a mushroom cart in action, you better get your tickets to Next! On the cart, there were several types of mushroom: matsutake, white beech, morel, enoki and shiitake.

These mushrooms made their way into a wonderful mushroom risotto, featuring farro rather than rice. I believe the risotto also incorporated black truffle and sunflower puree. The risotto was creamy, but with the farro still retaining some light crunch. And while I would have been thrilled to find some parmesan and butter lurking somewhere in this bowl, I must say I would be perfectly content to find a bowl of this risotto placed in front of me at any meal. The risotto was paired with a terrific 2009 Barolo by Parusso.
Mushroom Cart - Mushroom Risotto with Farro
Alex Stupak was the pastry chef when Alinea first opened (now he has two Mexican restaurants in New York) and was credited with part of the next course, called red onion, and done in the style of a Thai larb. Stupak got credit for the quinoa wire, the thin, crispy strip (made of quinoa) that rest upon the larb. I don't recall what was used to create the green puree painted on the plate, but it ultimately served as the cool component to the spicy larb. The larb gained its richness from heavily caramelized onions, but also incorporated red peppers for some real heat, as well as cilantro. This course was tasty, although I wish they had brought in a fermented bean paste or the like to make up for the absence of fish sauce. This course was accompanied by a fantastic Pinot Gris from Alsace, Schlumberger Grand Cru Spiegel, 2007.
Red Onion | Inspired by StupakThe final savory course of the evening was also an excuse for more fun - this time, a log with test tubes filled with seeds/sprouts serving as branches.

We were then presented with what may have been the most photogenic course of the evening, curry roasted cauliflower atop what I believe was a wonderfully aromatic and spicy harissa (and maybe curry) sauce. There was also a single chopstick on the table, and we were instructed to insert the chopstick into a test tube and push out the components (spices and a root with leaves - can't recall if it was soybean or chickpea). The charred cauliflower was terrific, and the silky smooth sauce was even better. It was also served with a very good, charred naan. With no ghee in either the sauce or the naan, I was stunned just how good this dish was.

Curry Roasted Cauliflower and NaanDid I mention that the sauce was not very good?

It's a good thing I had the naan.

Our introduction to dessert had two components, a teaspoon of olive oil jam with a Szechuan button, named so because of its slightly tingly, slightly numbing effect. The effect was rather subtle, far less than that of a Szechuan peppercorn (and unrelated to that plant), and quite short in duration.
The other component to this dessert was a bowl of chocolate, black truffle, strawberry and more of the olive oil jam. The chocolate had a sponge-like texture, reminding me of the microwaved cake served during the El Bulli menu. The chocolate-black truffle combination was both sweet and earth, and freeze-dried strawberry added a very interesting component to the dish. I don't know exactly how the olive oil/Szechuan button combination were supposed to pair with the bitter chocolate portion, but I nonetheless enjoyed this course.

Olive Oil Jam and Bitter Chocolate - olive oil jam and Szechuan button in top picture
Without question, my favorite course of the evening was our main dessert course. There were shortbread crumbs (can't remember what they used in place of butter here), pistachio, hibiscus syrup, a very cold, but melting vanilla yogurt of sorts encased in a thin shell that when cracked oozed the frozen dessert, and a hibiscus-swirled yogurt (or frozen dessert). There were quite a few components here, but all of them were outstanding and worked together perfectly. And it was plated (okay, tree trunked) beautifully. I'm not sure milk, cream, eggs or butter could have improved this dish. It was served with a delicious, rich and smoky cocktail comprised of Lambrusco, Mezcal and Carpano Antica, perhaps a smoky negroni?
Hibiscus and PistachioMignardises followed - called steamed crepes. There were three per person, one passion fruit, one chocolate and the last I think was vanilla. They were very light, almost like miniature sponge cakes, but delicious.
Steamed CrepesOverall, a terrific meal. Other than the main dessert though, I wouldn't say there was anything I loved. But I really enjoyed the food, and I loved the overall experience (and left quite full by the way). If you get excited about food, and you love to read and talk about it, and learn new things, I don't know how you wouldn't be excited to explore this menu. This is like diving from 50 meters when you've never gone diving before - it is such an in-depth exploration of vegan cuisine, and many ingredients I've never tried, at the very least in the way they were presented. Perhaps most amazing to me is that Next and its staff - proud omnivores to be sure - were able to develop so many delicious courses without fish, meat and dairy, but with so many different flavors. And though I really don't have significant knowledge when it comes to vegan food, I wouldn't doubt if they were in totally uncharted waters in terms of the food and courses they developed. In my opinion, this menu might have been their greatest feat.
Unfortunately, my curiosity coupled with my lack of knowledge of vegan foods might also have led to my one disappointment with the evening. All of our servers were very nice and professional. But they didn't really possess significant knowledge beyond the basics of what they has probably been told about the food. Ask questions and they seemed to merely repeat what they had already told you. We mention a dish is normally made with butter, or with eggs, and we ask how did they achieve a certain texture/flavor without those ingredients, and we couldn't obtain answers (a couple of times we were given obviously wrong information). This is the menu where I think the staff needed to be on top of its game, and needed to be taught quite a bit about the food. I doubt the restaurant is simply filled with people with $100 bills falling out of their wallets - there are people dining at Next seriously intrigued by cuisine and admittedly unsophisticated about this type of dining. I supposed it's one thing to show up at an expensive steakhouse and find professional yet unknowledgeable servers. But I would expect (perhaps incorrectly) Next to educate their servers at a different level. And at the same time we were hoping for some more information about the food, Francis Lam was dining near us and had visits during nearly every course from Chef Beran. I wish I could have been a fly on the wall during some of the discussions. In fairness, many may not have had the same curiosity, but for me, this was the one small negative of the evening.
Well, there was also Next's ubiquitous leaflet explaining the menu concept - surprise, surprise, they're omnivores. Personally, I would rather read along with the menu as they're describing it, and have them do away with this almost rote menu presentation.
But minor complaints aside, I thought this was a terrific menu and a fascinating exploration of a food type I've never before cared to explore. I highly recommend a visit. It's easy to sit back and say you're not interested in vegan food (as I would normally do), but just remember whose hands you've placed these veggies in. And for those concerned with statistics, our meal lasted just shy of three hours, and was very well paced.
Last edited by
BR on June 4th, 2013, 12:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.