as an infrequent contributor, frequent reader, and a pal with one of the city editors, I officially want to say: RIP (non-NYC edition) Grub Street.
I don't know about analysis, but GS is known, site-wide, to be an antagonist submerged in the foodie movement. They will mock the shit out of you, as good New Yorkers are want to do, while reporting the "news". And they paid decent, unlike Village Voice/Curbed Network.