Father's Day Catering- Arlington Heights/Mount Prospect area

Suddenly, Mr. Maki and I are hosting Father's Day in our new house in Arlington Heights. Any suggestions for a restaurant to to carry-out/catering from in the Arlington Heights or Mount Prospect area?

Something that isn't too expensive (Dave's Specialty Foods is out) and isn't too "exotic" (most of the Asian in the area is out).

We were thinking of either Mago Grill, Salerno's, or T-Bob's BBQ.

It would be for 7 adults and 4 kids, age 11 and under. One of the kids has a dairy allergy, so I'm not counting him, and who knows if the others will even eat any of it. Seems like most catering trays start at 8-10 portions, so any kids we can feed is just a bonus, but the moms usually bring their own food for the picky little beasts.

Any ideas?

Giacomo's
740 N Wolf Rd Des Plaines, IL 60016
(847) 390-7330

Nino's Pizza
960 S Buffalo Grove Rd Buffalo Grove, IL 60089
(847) 947-4111

Capri Deli
1625 N Rand Rd, Palatine, IL 60074
(847) 359-9106