Zizi's has been recommended to me a lot recently so I finally decided to give it a try.
From the website I immediately recognized Zeynel (he's standing with Omer Asik) who used to be the primary server over at Turquoise. For years Turquoise was my go to Turkish restaurant but they proved to be inconsistent and lately I've preferred Cafe Orchid.
I'm sorry to report that my first meal at Zizi's was pretty hit and miss. In fairness this was a delivery order so it's possible the food does better in the restaurant.
The food ranged from awful to good with everything in between. I was thrilled to see celery root on the menu since you rarely see that at Turkish restaurants in the US. I should've read the menu more carefully because what they're serving is indistinguishable from gloppy cole slaw. A far cry from
zeytin yagli kerevis. The eggplant salad had great texture and lots of smoky flavor but no balance at all. It tasted like eggplant with olive oil with no flavor imparted from the red onion or the parsley (or lemon juice for that matter). Bummer, cuz the eggplant itself had a lot of promise. The doner tasted like classic gyro meat, which is fine, but not what I was hoping for from a local Turkish joint.
On the flip side, I enjoyed the adana kebab which had nice gamey flavor though lacked any spice at all which is the hallmark of adana kebab. Still it was a good kebab. The lentil fingers were earthy and somewhat spicy, a solid rendition though not as good as the version at Cafe Orchid. The pide with sucuk was also solid but I'd really like it if someone would offer a rendition using a spicier sucuk and kashar cheese. I just can't get excited about pide made with mozzarella. Finally, the star of the meal, for me, was the ezme. The balance was right on with great depth and heat from the pepper paste and plenty of walnuts.
I wish Zeynel luck and I was disappointed they were out of the lahmacun since that was my favorite dish at Turquoise so I was hoping Zizi's could follow suit. There are a number of Turkish restaurants a couple blocks from my house so I don't know if I'll make it back to Zizi's to try it again any time soon.