Stung by a 1 hour, 45 minute quoted wait time at Fat Rice tonight right at the opening bell, a few of us decided to instead check out Analogue. No offense Fat Rice, but thank you for your assistance! As excited as I was when I first tried Fat Rice, I think I might have been even more excited this evening at Analogue. I hardly know how to express my excitement with Analogue but food, cocktails and service all blew me away and I suppose I'll restate a lot of what Ronnie says above.
We arrived right when it opened at 6, were warmly welcomed and decided to sit at the bar. FYI, there are also several tables along the wall, and a few high tops in front. We proceeded to eat our way through much of the menu.
First, the biscuits. Warm, flaky, delicious, and served with Steen's cane syrup butter and a hot pepper jelly. The biscuits are great on their own, but I couldn't ignore the hot pepper jelly which delivered a nice, hot little sting. The butter was perfectly fine too, but I just didn't need it. Best biscuits? Not for me (still Bang Bang and Acadia) but who cares. They're terrific.
The smoked fish dip was served in a ball with saltines and hot sauce on the side. I probably should have tried the dip with the hot sauce, but the fish dip was so fantastic on its own I just didn't mix them. I'm not sure I've ever had a better smoked fish dip.
The Scott, Louisiana egg was another stunner to me. Yes, the exterior was nice and crisp. Yes, the boudin (house-made by the way) was terrific. But then the perfectly cooked egg, the mustard and just the combination of flavors left me speechless. This might have been the best scotch egg I've tried.
I've had a number of gumbos in Chicago that are acceptable. Occasionally, I've enjoyed the gumbo at Big Jones but it really has never rocked my world. Personally, I've always preferred my own and take great pride in annually ordering my andouille and tasso from Wayne Jacob's in LaPlace, La. Well folks, this is some damn fine gumbo with one hell of a roux there to tickle your taste buds. But here's the kicker: the chef, Alfredo, mentioned that he spent a little time at Wayne Jacob's paying attention to their smoking techniques and makes his own andouille for Analogue's gumbo. Once you taste the gumbo and the andouille, you'll realize that Alfredo knows more than a thing or two about andouille and gumbo. Oh, and the potato salad: not something I've ever tried and I'll admit I had never heard of this addition, but it worked.
And sorry, but the hits just kept on coming. The cochon de lait po-boy was pretty spectacular too. The pork was almost like pork candy, but not in a sweet way - some parts crisp, all parts juicy and full of pork richness, and then a perfectly crusty yet soft roll. I'll usually dab a little hot sauce on my po-boys but there was no way I was going to screw with this forumula. No way.
And how did I go this long without talking about the dirty rice. You could smell the rich offal flavors the instant this was placed in front of us. It was also incredibly difficult to stop eating this. My dining companions compared the mixture to a great Thai larb, and I could definitely see that - just missing the Thai herbs, but it was every bit as good. Dirty rice has never, ever tasted this good. In my opinion, a must order.
Also quite impressive was the chaurice dog. It's served on a soft, buttered lobster roll bun and accentuated with some rich red beans and tart chow chow, but it was the moist, snappy and delicious house-made chaurice that really thrilled me.
Finally, the fried chicken sandwich. It's hard to take issue which a flavorful, crispy, moist chicken sandwich. But my small criticisms would be that I would have preferred the more flavorful thigh meat, and I thought the chicken was just slightly lost in the slaw and pickles. But hey, I still enjoyed it quite a bit.
We shared a bread pudding for dessert and while not one of my favorite bread puddings, it was still very good. I just prefer a slightly moister, denser bread pudding.
I also had a couple of cocktails (and tried a few others) and was very impressed on that front too. I loved my Pressure Drop, which featured Banks 5 Island Rum, lime, banana falernum, pineapple and mint - a restrained, interesting and delicious tiki-like drink. Unfortunately, I can't recall all details of my other cocktail (which I also enjoyed quite a bit), though I know it contained gin and grapefruit.
As I mentioned, service throughout the night was great. Everyone who we came in contact with and who helped us was friendly, considerate and helpful. One small note in this regard: when the gumbo was brought out, they also gave us three small bowls so that we could share the gumbo, and we didn't even need to ask for them. We left Analogue at about 7:45, by which time it had completely filled up and there may have even been a couple of people waiting for a table. I would imagine it's not very long before the wait times start growing significantly. This place is just that good.