This was a truly remarkable dinner and really one of my favorite meals of the year. Now it's not lost on me that Gary is prominent on LTH and perhaps there are many who visit here who are then skeptical about the rave reviews. For those of you who might feel this way, I'm truly sorry you didn't get a chance to enjoy this meal, which ranks among the very best bbq meals I've had. But give one of these pitmaster meals a try - a small investment for a ton of great food (with cocktails and leftovers too).
The evening started with grilled garlic bread and New Orleans bbq shrimp. I would have liked some crispness and char to the garlic bread, but I can't complain about the flavor, which delivered the perfect amounts of both butter and garlic.
The bbq shrimp was fantastic. The shrimp were just perfectly cooked (very lightly smoked indeed) and the sauce was every bit as delicious and buttery as you'd expect and demand. What sauce remained in the serving dish was perfect for sopping up with the garlic bread.
I've had goose breast on a few previous occasions, and it's usually been on the dry side. The hickory smoked goose breast this evening was easily the best goose I've ever had -- just enough fat, plenty of moist meat, and I loved how the hickory smoke was just one of the accent flavors and didn't overwhelm at all. In my opinion, only those who have really perfected their bbq'ing skills show the proper restraint with smoke.
I went back and forth between the hickory smoked goose breast and the goose breast pastrami in terms of which one I preferred. But as excellent as the pastrami was, I just kept coming back to the hickory smoked goose breast. But both were fantastic.
There was also wild rice with bourbon cherries and smoked almonds. I don't know that I recall the cherries and almonds coming through strongly, but I enjoyed the nutty wild rice quite a bit. There was also a green bean casserole with bacon. I'll be honest - I typically hate green bean casserole. But this was tolerable, even kind of tasty, thanks to the beans retaining some texture and the absence of thick cream.
I was pretty full by the time dessert came, but I really enjoyed the bread pudding, and in particular the rye soaked dates and figs.
I've been to several of the pitmaster dinners and they're always a blast. But this was easily my favorite -- still dreaming of that hickory smoked goose. It really was the stuff of dreams.