Though I haven't yet made it to
Gather, it is a well-liked newcomer to the neighborhood.
Other places I enjoy, off the top of my head:
Tiny Lounge - good cocktails and respectable shareables menu in a loungey ambiance (no reservations)
Fork - wine bar and range of dinner options (yes reservations)
Aroy Thai (or
Rainbow Thai if you love food, but ambiance does not matter at all) - both BYOB, no reservations
Bistro Campagne (yes reservations)
Fountainhead - fantastic beer and whiskey selection and pretty good food (no reservations)
I'm also a huge fan of Bad Apple (mentioned upthread). I never tried the Mediterranean Grill or the Indian place because of all the other great places that serve those cuisines outside of Lincoln Square. But if you have a hankering ... you're really only limited by what you're in the mood for.
The meal isn't over when I'm full; the meal is over when I hate myself. - Louis C.K.