There are a lot of interesting brunches, but ones that take reservations and are close to downtown narrows things down. Our very best breakfast-focused restaurants -
Jam,
M. Henry,
Southport Grocery,
Bongo Room - do not accept reservations. And they all tend to have lengthy waits to be seated between roughly 9:30 and 1:00. If you can go earlier or later than that, you probably won't have to wait.
Shaw's Crab House is one of my favorites for Sunday brunch, but it's not a typical brunch so it may or may not be what you're looking for. If you enjoy seafood and think of it as a mid-day dinner, it's sheer heaven. They serve an all-you-can-eat buffet, including breakfast items (the best thick-cut caramelized bacon in the world, crabmeat benedicts), lunch/dinner items (Chicago's best crab cakes, hot or cold Alaskan king crab legs yes all you can eat of those too, a carving station), and wonderful desserts (crème brulee, chocolate pot de crème). Not cheap at $55/person but you'll be stuffed for the rest of the day.
I've been to a lot of other Sunday brunches around town that accept reservations, some of them very good, but no one brunch that stands out as head and shoulders above the rest. If I had to name just one, it would probably be
Perennial Virant (EDIT - but see below). I've also had a very good brunch at
Salpicon. Of those already mentioned,
Nightwood is good.
Big Jones is also good (love the beignets) but quite a distance from downtown.
My strategy for choosing a Sunday brunch is similar to yours (strong preference for places that accept reservations, to avoid the typical 30-60 minute waits at those that don't) and Frank's (look at listings on Opentable), and check website menus. Sometimes that works out quite nicely. A week ago, I looked on Opentable, then looked at menus, and made a reservation for
Max's Wine Dive, a Texas-based chain I had never heard of and which has a location in Wicker Park. We went there and it was excellent - not that unusual, but very well executed. It was not quite full, maybe 75 percent of the tables were taken. Afterwards we walked out and noticed the huge lines of people waiting inside Bongo Room and Xoco nearby, and thought Max's would be a no-brainer rather than have a long wait at those places.
EDIT - As I was typing this, stout posted a recommendation for
North Pond, which had slipped my mind.
North Pond would be my top recommendation (assuming you're not looking for a rather expensive seafood blowout at Shaw's). I love the exquisite setting in the middle of the park. I've only been there for dinner, but it's been absolutely terrific. And the brunch price is a bargain for the quality of the restaurant, $34 for the three-course prix fixe menu. When making your reservation, make a request to be seated in the front room, with the full-length windows facing the pond (although the rear room with the open kitchen is fun too).
ANOTHER EDIT - If you want to keep it conveniently close in the Loop itself,
Atwood, in the Hotel Burnham, recently re-opened after remodeling. Their new chef, Brian Millman, has a breakfast/brunch-focused background (Uncommon Ground). They accept reservations including on Opentable. The brunch menu on their website sounds impressive. I've only been there in its previous iteration, but the Kimpton hotels do a great job of attracting and keeping top culinary talent in their restaurants.
Last edited by
nsxtasy on March 12th, 2015, 9:59 am, edited 9 times in total.