One of my best pals is a wine guy in Bordeaux, he's also a former writer for Gault et Millau. I asked him to read this thread, and pls comment. Which he graciously did. Here are his comments. I trust his advice totally.
Geo
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
As to the restaurant scene in Bordeaux, I would agree with just about everyone’s comments on the chat board you attached with two exceptions: Grand Barrail in Saint Emilion is too far outside the village to be within walking distance and the food’s been going downhill ever since the chef left, the one who’s now in charge of the Hostellerie de Plaisance, actually in the town of St. Emilion. The place to which you refer is indeed the Envers du Décor. The food is nothing fancy but you can eat, weather permitting, in the interior courtyard and the wine list is progressive with interesting wines from all over France. The owner, François des Ligneris, used to be the owner of Ch. Soutard but his family sold it about two months ago. That’s why he showed one of the “chatters” Soutard after he’d enjoyed a meal at the Envers. Hostellerie de Plaisance is the best restaurant on the Right Bank although the St. James in Bouliac above the Garonne River with striking views of Bordeaux, is making something of a comeback.
La Tupiña seems to be a favorite of many Americans perhaps because so many of them seem to equate the size of the dish with its quality. And if they’re stuffed to the gills when they leave a restaurant, it MUST have been good. It IS good, classical rotisserie fare, my favorite is the 7-hour lamb. For foie gras and frites lovers, it is also very good. The wine list, however, has always struck me as unexciting and over-priced.
For a great wine list, an interesting décor 15th century vaulted cellar in the old part of the city, I like Les Jardins d’Ausone, owned by wine merchant, Laurent Vialatte. The food is very good but far lighter than the fare at La Tupiña! It’s the only place in Bordeaux – or possibly France – where you can drink great German Rieslings from the 1970’s and 1980’s! And that for around $50.00, tax and tip included (the two of which represent nearly 33% of the check amount).
I think Cordeillan-Bages is over-rated and it is also an hour-plus drive up to Pauillac from Bordeaux. Lots of wine people like the Lion d’Or in Arcins, probably because they can bring their own wine and are actually encouraged to do so (the wine list is boring). The fare is similar in inspiration to La Tupiña. The chef is loud and vociferous giving the place some character!
For good pizza, there are two places: the very “hip” Chez Peppone. Good food, good ingredients and a better than average (for France) Italian wine list. For better pizza at lower prices, there’s also Jacomo in the old part of the city. Very thin crust, flavorful pizzas for people who appreciate pizza not bread. The owner, Bernadette, is a gregarious, foul-mouthed but funny, hostess. Not for those without a sense of humor.
There is also a place just across the river with fantastic views of the city riverfront, one of the prettiest in France, that serves decent seafood and has a decent wine list. It’s called L’Estoquade.
Finally, there is the restaurant called Gravelier, which is owned by the daughter of one of the Troisgros brothers (*** Michelin restaurant in Roanne) and her husband whose family name is . . . Gravelier. Fairly priced, well-executed food with a short, but good, wine list.
P.S. Darroze in Langon is good but not probably worth the 45’ drive unless one has other reasons to be in the southern Graves and Sauternes region.
Sooo, you like wine and are looking for something good to read? Maybe
*this* will do the trick!
