Had a good meal at Milt’s last night. The place was fairly full by 6pm but they let us sit at the bar (3 adults) and window seats (2 teens). We started with a plate of their sliders shared between me and the teens. I liked the pulled chicken with their house made tomato and vinegar sauce but the brisket version just did not do it for me (“soft” texture, no noticeable smoke flavor and no bark for contrast). The hidden surprise was the burger slider, which while engulfed by the bun, packed a great char flavor. I could have eaten 3-4 of these.
For mains, the two teens had the fried chicken (tenders?) sandwiches of which there was nothing left for me to sample and the fries looked as good as the teen girls said. For the three adults we each ordered the half chicken, me making it a combo with the beef ribs. Each bbq platter came with a side choice and slaw, vinegar or creamy. The vinegar version was just okay but I really liked the creamy version that was not overly creamy and had a good blend of spices against the crisp cabbage.
Sides were sautéed spinach, baked beans with brisket (poorly set for myself a Smoqe-esq expectation– see comment on brisket above) and corn bread that was more like dense cake but very enjoyable as my desert at the end of the meal - no spread required. The forth side was lightly sautéed green beans that I am still thinking about this morning. Plump, bright green in color with no blemishes, firm/crisp to the bite and accompanied by a very soft touch of caramelized onions.
My two adult companions enjoyed their half chickens. I on the other hand detected a bitter taste that could have been a smoke issue in the breast meat (tasted like charcoal – but bartender/waiter indicated they use applewood) . All pieces were moist and I did enjoy the thigh. The star of my plate was the two very large smoked beef ribs (longest I have seen at about 9-10 inches). A good but mild smoke flavor (I like heavy, so this may need to be calibrated) combined with spice rub that created a great bark and minimal fat except for the underlying layer. I would like to eat a plateful of these again but for the price (dreaming of Victoria Station last night as I was going off to sleep not because of the price but the never ending supply of beef ribs).
Service was okay, perhaps a little slow if you go in thinking “bbq”. We were seated by 6:15 and paid the check at 8. The party next to us was seated shortly after and were out 30 minutes earlier. Total bill was $177 for five of us with one beer, one soda and a single desert (my wife ordered bread pudding but was told it is seasonal so opted for what they call peach cobbler – I did not partake). An issue that had me shaking my head was that my combo platter was $55 and included two sides +coleslaw, two ribs and half a chicken – admittedly that is two diner orders. The half chicken diner is priced at just under $19, so $36 for a two rib, albeit large, dinner. That was my fault as the menu does not list prices for the beef or chicken; just a “MP”, or market price notation, so I knew that there could be sticker shock and should have asked. Apparently beef ribs are the new skirt steak in terms of escalating prices for a previously discarded item. If asked I would go again, but not choose to on my own.
Sitting here about to hit submit on what will be perhaps my second post in three years - I notice its quite long and asked myself why. It’s because I had to explain to myself that at the end of the day, despite the price I had a meal with great company that hit several sweet spots but had an unexpected price tag. Sorry for bringing you into my self-help group.
Do Well,
Mike