One of the dilemmas of dining out in Chicago is that there are so many great restaurants, it's tough to get around to returning to places you've loved in the past. The newest restaurants get all the hype. Yet there are restaurants which are as good as ever, but because they've been around for a while, they "fly under the radar". So it is with Mexique, Carlos Gaytan's restaurant serving contemporary Mexican cuisine with a slight French flair in West Town. I ate there seven years ago and loved it. Yet I just didn't get around to returning until dinner last night. BIG MISTAKE because Chef Gaytan is still knocking it out of the park. The entire meal was absolutely wonderful, start to finish, every single dish. Unfortunately for the restaurant, it was mostly empty, which is a shame... but it meant that I was able to take flash photos without bothering other diners. So here goes.
The outside

The inside

The amuse bouche of chicken liver spread with a slightly spicy sauce

ENSALADA - Greens, pears, multi-color beets, goat cheese

MEJILLONES - PEI Mussels, White Wine, Dried Chorizo, Saffron Beurre Blanc, Pickled Jalapeno and Fennel - This was outstanding. You can't tell from the photo but the creamy sauce below the mussels was oh so yummy!

CEVICHE - the tart citrus dipping sauce went wonderfully with it

PESCAMAL - Seafood Mousse Tamal Cooked in Banana Leaves Stuffed with Crab Meat Fricassee, Lemon Confit and Spiced Bouillabaisse

PLATANO Y MANTARRAYA - Achiote/Tequila Pan Seared Skate Wing, Plantain, Cauliflower, Pickled Grapes, Spinach, Tomato/Habanero Beurre Blanc - you can't see it in the photo but the fish was served on a bed of a huge plantain slice

CORVINA - Pan Seared Corvina, risotto, cactus salad, lobster bisque

CORDERO - Herb Crusted Rack of Lamb, Coffee Braised Lamb Barbacoa Huarache, Eggplant Marmalade, Roasted Garlic Salsa

ARROZ CON LECHE - Rice pudding, white chocolate

PASTEL TRES LECHES - The traditional celebratory Mexican dessert; this was one of the best and lightest versions in the city

As I mentioned, all of these dishes were standouts, so it would be difficult to pick only one favorite. But if pressed, the most memorable were the mussels, the skate, and the tres leches cake.
Service was terrific, very knowledgeable and attentive without being overbearing. Chef Gaytan came by to say hello, which is always a nice touch (I'm not known as a friend of the house).
This dinner was absolutely wonderful. I strongly recommend Mexique, for those who have never been, as well as those who have been there and loved it but who, like myself, haven't been back in a while. ¡Bravo!
P.S. I hear Chef Carlos Gaytan won on Top Chef recently. Based on last night's dinner, I'm not surprised.
Last edited by
nsxtasy on July 22nd, 2017, 1:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.