I lost a bet that I need to pay (by mail, which rules out some options) in Chicago foodstuffs to a downstate cousin. (When one of these bets goes the other way, I get a box of Taylor's chili from Carlinville.)
I haven't ruled out the tastesofchicago.com option, but because my cousin is a Cardinals fan and his wife is from Lincolnshire, the idea I like best at the moment is a box of Fannie May chocolates, because I could put a note to my cousin-in-law at the bottom of the card that my cousin would not fail to notice: "p.s., don't tell him that Fannie May is the official chocolate candy of the Chicago Cubs!"
"Your swimming suit matches your eyes, you hold your nose before diving, loving you has made me bananas!"