Rene G wrote:Hmm. So how does H&A stack up with, say, MacArthur's or Johnson's?
Late last year I ate almost the same meal at MacArthur’s and H&A on successive days. I’m a fan of MacArthur’s but I have to say H&A came out well ahead in this comparison. The meal at H&A probably cost a couple dollars more though.
This old Chowhound post has the head-to-head comparison. I haven’t tried too many dishes in common at H&A and Johnson’s (8233 S Ashland) so really can’t comment. All three are good. You’ll just have to see which you prefer.
Actually, I think I had read that old post of yours, but had completely forgotten
about it (and after thinking at the time that I oughta try the place too - this
is why I need to write things down more
Wish I *had* remembered it (or read your post earlier, not sure when you
wrote it). Dropped by H&A yesterday, before reading the above
Had the fried chicken with the 2 sides - potatoes-and-gravy, and mac-n-cheese.
And the chicken noodle soup. The woman asked about bread roll or corn
muffin, and I said corn muffin... and then, as she was picking one out, suddenly
that line from your previouis post about "great rolls" popped into my head, and
I requested a reversal of the order just in time.
The fried chicken was decent, but not the *best* Ive had (Ive had better, maybe
because it was fresher, at Hecky's up in Evanston - went in about 1:30 in
the afternoon there and asked for their 1/4 chicken, and they said Id have to
wait a good 10 minutes. I happily agreed, because that means it goes right
in the fryer comes out completely fresh and hot - that was a better
version than H&A, but H&A's wasnt bad at all). The soup was actually
quite good. The potatoes and gravy were decent, but they skimped on the
gravy - if I had read your Chowhound post earlier or remembered it on how
good their gravy was, would have watched closely and insisted they pour
more on

The mac-n-cheese was very good - better than even the fresh
version I remember from MacArthur's. And the dinner rolls - absoutely
terrific, am so glad your last post popped into my head just in time, they were
light and moist and really excellent.
Overall, a couple bucks more than Mac's as you said, and this meal yesterday
was comparable but doesnt yet displace Mac's for me - but then I seem not
to have tried their best stuff (the gravy and other "wet" items you mention).
The bread rolls were better than anything at Mac's, as was one side - the
other could have been with more gravy probably, but the chicken itself
wasnt clearly better than Ive had at Mac's in the past. But, of course, this
is in a totally different location - and when one is near 55th, one really has
no shot at getting to Mac's when hungry anyway, so why even compare?
Thanks much for the rec, will definitely be back, and likely more than once -
on Sundays in the area especially, there arent too many options of that quality
IMHO. I preferred H&A's to my one trip to Johnson's, and it is much much
more convenient as well (and with a couple more trips I might well prefer
it to Mac's too, who knows, except for Mac's amazingly low prices

Clearly
its up there among the best soul food places - and its so convenient when
Iam in the area, and I had *no* idea about it until your post. So thanks
again
(Was actually in the area on both Saturday and Sunday, and did Barbara Ann's
on Saturday, tips and links. Tried the hot sauce this time, which was actually
a bit hotter than ideal for that meat IMHO, sort of overpowered it - will return to
the milder version from now on. Good tips, and their links continue to be
IMHO easily the finest in the city. Even the fries were better than usual
this time, maybe they had just come out of the fryer. The only way BA
falls short of perfection on their links is their inability to provide them to
hungry customers on Sundays
c8w
P.S. Drove down Garfield to the highway, but again didnt notice Mrs Lee's
while driving by (though I wasnt actually slowing and looking hard, and
sort of recalled it was on the way but not the exact address). It isnt a
really big or prominent place, I take it? Next time will make sure to take
the exact address with me, along with the nearest cross-street etc, and
make sure to find it, if only to pick up some dessert on the way home.