I just returned, happily satiated, from a 5-day trip to New Orleans. My dining options were guided by posts on this board as well as some convergence of information on what to try from other sources. Although I've been to New Orleans on two other occasions, both of my previous trips were too short to really sample the great food that NO has to offer.
Below I highlight some of my eating experiences and impressions. Given my previous lack of experience with NO cuisine, I lack the ability to compare many of the things I ate to their culinary "gold standards." The posts below are of well-known establishments, so my comments will not likely bring about any revelations. That said, I hope my experiences underscore the great NO recommendations already found on this board. Thanks to those of you that have posted on this thread for making my senses (primarily taste and smell) so happy over the past few days. I can't wait to return to New Orleans.
Mother's
Our first meal was at Mother's, which seems to be a New Orleans institution. It's a very casual atmosphere with food served "cafeteria-style." We stopped in for lunch and ordered a
cup of gumbo, a
cup of red beans and rice, a
cup of jambalaya, a serving of
potato salad, a
pecan brownie and a
Ferdi's Special PoBoy (baked ham, roast beef, debris, cabbage, pickles, mayo, mustard, and gravy). "Debris" was bits and pieces of roast beef that seem to have fallen of from the roast, received more cooking, and were simmering in gravy. The PoBoy was very tasty, but the bread didn't hold up too well to all the rich, juicy, gravy. It got very wet. The mingling of most of the flavors was great, but next time I'm at Mother's I think I would opt for the baked ham or roast beef (alone), and not mix the two together. The potato salad was disappointing – it was rather dry, with a homogenously bland flavor. It didn't really have a whole lot going on ; seemed like mashed potatoes and some spices. My wife and I found the gumbo tasty, but not particularly great. The two real treats in the meal were the jambalaya and the red beans and rice. The red beans and rice were delicious – plump, juicy, in a very flavorful, thick liquid – rice on the bottom and pieces of Andouille sausage tossed in for extra flavor. It was rich, smoky, and a touch of heat. This was my favorite. The jambalaya also had a wonderfully complex smoky flavor, but what I really loved was its texture. It was just the right amount of wet, with each rice grain maintaining a firm, yet yielding, consistency. The brownie was good.
Brigsten's
Our arrival at Brigtsen's was marred by a mishap for which I am only to blame. It's a long story that would be completely off topic, but the important part is that I lost my wallet in the cab that took me there. I let the hostess know my situation up-front in case the taxi driver would return to the establishment. I could not praise the hospitality I received at Brigtsen's enough – genuine Southern charm, warmth, and hospitality. I was soaking wet, since it was pouring outside and I ran after the cab as soon as I realized the wallet was missing. Minutes after being seated, our waitress comes to the table and says she was so sorry to hear about my wallet, gave me a very warm, appropriate, and genuine hug, and proceeded to read my mind by instantly saying, "I bet you need a drink." She was right. My wife and I were both calm and ready to enjoy ourselves – we had decided there was nothing much we could do about the wallet until we returned to the hotel, so we didn't let the mishap interfere with our enjoyment of the meal. The service was great all night – they anticipated all of my needs. Our camera was on the table; they asked if we would like our picture taken since we were "such a good looking couple." What charmers! As we were wrapping up dessert, the hostess came back to our table with a paper and pen so we could jot down our information, in case the taxi driver returned. They also had a cab waiting for us before we even asked for it. All needs anticipated and taken care of – what more can you ask for in terms of service? There was one misstep: the béarnaise sauce for my wife's entrée broke. I got my entrée and we had to wait for about 5 minutes more before hers arrived. They were appropriately apologetic (i.e., it was genuine and not obsequious), and comped my wife's glass of wine. I LOVED the fact they came to us right away and told us exactly what had gone wrong without us having to ask them. They owned up to their mistake right away and dealt with it as soon as possible. As you can read, I really enjoyed the service. I've had plenty of top-end service before, but I've never experienced a place were the servers were so warm, charming, genuine, AND professional. They really made me happy to be there. The restaurant itself is in an old Victorian home, with the various rooms turned into dining areas with a limited number of tables. Rather than tearing the walls down to make a large dinning area, it seems they kept the rooms fairly intact. I liked it. The place did look a bit old (and it is); the wear was visible on the walls (the paint on some was dirty and cracking), windowsills, and corners (many collecting dust and a bit dirty). How about the food you ask? Others here have attested to how good the food is at Brigtsen's, and my wife and I wholeheartedly agree. Everything we ate was great. These guys are not afraid of using butter: thank goodness!!!!! Here's what we had:
Sauteed Softshell Crab with Spiced Pecans & Lemon Bordelaise Sauce
[My favorite for the night. The crab juicy, luscious, and beautifully breaded. Soft, moist, and warm inside, with a deliciously crispy and crunchy exterior. The sauce was sweet and acidic, with a nice touch of heat.]
Broiled Gulf Fish with Crabmeat Parmesan Crust, Asparagus, Mushrooms, & Bearnaise
[This was my wife's entrée. The crust on this fish was incredible. The fish was very tasty and delicate. It was in no way overpowered by the sauce, but rather beautifully complimented. The béarnaise had a delicious depth, partially added by a subtle but pervasive flavor of tarragon.]
Red grouper with Crabmeat, Shrimp, & Meuniere Sauce
[Simple, incredibly fresh, and delicious.]
Pecan Pie with Caramel Sauce & Vanilla Ice Cream
[The crust on this was so delicate and flaky. The caramel sauce tasted very fresh and natural. It was light and the caramelized sugar taste and smell permeated the dish.]
Central Grocery
This small Italian specialty foods store seems to specialize in making one thing and making it great:
Muffaletta. Of all the places we tried, this is the one place I can actually see myself eating at least once a week. Simple: a big piece of Italian round bread with sesame seeds, slices of delicious salami, mortadella, and provolone. There may have been some other meats and cheese in mixed in there, but I can't tell you what they were. The best thing is their delicious olive tapenade that tops the meats. This is a super thick and chunky, vinegary, oily, and delectable marinated salad of what looked to me like green olives, cauliflower, celery carrot, with Italian seasonings on top. All of those flavors mixed together so well. I'm actually going to stop writing about it, because I am craving one right now. Here is a picture of what a quarter of the sandwich looks like:
Restaurant August
I'd be lying if I said we went to August because Chef John Besh recently won a James Beard award for Best Chef, Southeast, for 2006. It was actually seeing him triumph over Mario Batali in Iron Chef America – Battle Andouille sausage – that prompted the visit. Luckily, August is open for lunch, which allowed us to sample their top-notch cuisine in a more inexpensive manner. It's a real shame I didn't have my camera to take pictures of the beautifully presented courses that we ate. For appetizers, my wife had a
goat-cheese stuffed trio of figs wrapped in ham. The figs were not heavily caramelized and tasted very light and fresh. The ham was very thinly sliced and full of flavor. These sweet and savory dumplings of joy appeared to be heated up a bit to sweat out some of the flavors. I had a
beet salad with mixed greens, goat cheese, and some of the most hammy, smoky, delicious bacon pieces that I've ever had. For her entree, my wife had preparation of
blackfish and corn (there was more to this, but neither of us remembers). I had a deliciously prepared
veal panee. The veal was tender and succulent, thinly sliced but very juicy, with a light and crispy breading. The veal was accompanied with artichokes and small tomatoes of many different colors and sizes (some peeled others not). The whole thing was covered in a light, acidic sauce that coalesced perfectly with the breaded veal. More figs for desert – a fresh
fig tart with lemongrass sorbet. The desert was spectacular. The figs were very fresh and appeared to be poached rather than darkly caramelized (as I'm used to seeing in fig desserts). This made the desert very light. Coupled with the lemongrass sorbet and a sweet anise and mint sauce, this desert was incredibly refreshing. Find some scientist to condense and concentrate all of those flavors into a breath mint and I'll be sucking on it all day. It was a perfect ending to the lunch. The service was friendly and efficient. The restaurant itself seemed a bit old and worse for the wear. I don't know if this is a consequence of Katrina. I can't wait to return to New Orleans and try their dinner.
Other things worth mentioning, for the sake of completeness
We also had a quick lunch at the
Acme Oyster House. We had an appetizer of
fried crawfish tails with a side of a fairly standard spicy, piquant red sauce.
Hush puppies were very yummy, I could pop this mini-nuggets of spicy sweet corn all day. My wife had
jambalaya and I had a
fried shrimp and oyster PoBoy. All the food items were good and service was fast, if very bare-bones. The jambalaya was not as fresh as that at Mother's. Nothing to write home about: just a decent meal in a sports-bar like setting. We also had the mandatory
beignets at
Café du Monde – these were great: joyous billowy pillows of eggy fried dough drenched in an orgy of powdered sugar – hot and good. We had them again at a second Café du Monde location, but found them to be rather flat and and not nearly as nicely executed. Finally, I'd like to make a few comments on
New Orleans French bread as I experienced it at Brigsten's, August, and Acme. I don't know if this is representative, but the "French bread" served in each of these locations is the closest thing I've had to Cuban bread outside of Hialeah (in Miami, FL). The resemblance was surprising, though not quite Cuban bread by most standards. Definitely more Cuban than anything I've had in Chicago. The crust was not hard and solid, but rather hugged the bread like a thin sleeve (though not as thin as the Cuban bread I like). The texture of the bread suggested the presence of lard, with a soft and meaty interior.
Pre-Post Katrina?
Given my lack of experience with NO pre-Katrina, I can't say much about how much the cuisine and business has suffered. This past week, New Orleans was jumping. All businesses that I could see in the French Quarter, Central Business District, Warehouse District, and Uptown were open and kicking. There was also plenty of "HIRING" signs all over the place. I couldn't rave about my time there enough and I can't wait to return. It's incredible that things are already so vibrant with all of the devastation and loss that many individuals are grappling with. Hopefully the fast recovery of downtown New Orleans will serve to help those in less fortunate areas to get their lives back on track.
Mother's Restaurant
401 Poydras St
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 523-9656
Brigtsen's New Orleans
723 Dante St
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 861-7610
Central Grocery Co.
923 Decatur St
New Orleans, LA 70116
(504) 523-1620
Restaurant August
301 Tchoupitoulas St
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 299-9777
Acme Oyster House
724 Iberville St
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 525-1160
Café du Monde Coffee House
800 Decatur St
New Orleans, LA
(504) 581-2914