Ok, a small private school down the street had a bake sale this week. I picked up a loaf that was marked "Mrs. Sheehan's Soda Bread". With a name like that, I figured I couldn't go wrong. Well, whoever she is, Mrs. Sheehan certainly outdid herself.
From the outside, the loaf was a golden caramel brown very much like a pound cake. The bread had plenty of sweet moist raisins, but the bread itself was not very sweet at all (I am using past tense because the loaf was gone in a couple of hours). It had a moist denseness and flavor that definitely came from buttermilk, but I am almost certain it had no actual butter (it was moist but not rich). Surprisingly, despite its density, the bread was very porous with larger air bubbles. In that respect, it was more like a yeast bread than a quick bread(I suspect the batter was still lumpy when it was poured into the pan). That gave it an airy texture that balanced its cake-like consistency.
What Mrs Sheehan's bread had, that I have not seen in these recipes, is Carraway seeds. Not a lot of them. Just enough to give a slight bitterness to the bread which contrasted wonderfully with the plump sweet raisins. In fact, the bread was all about contrasting textures, consistencies and flavors. Just wonderful. Needless to say, I went back to the bake sale the next day, looking for more of Mrs. Sheehan's delectable Soda Bread. Of course, the last loaf was long gone. Now, I guess I will have to wait until the next bake sale for more. Well anyhow, Happy St. Paddy's day to you, Mrs. Sheehan and all the rest of my Irish brethren.