I've been to Elliott's, which was okay the first time we were there, and exceptionally better the second time (about two weeks ago on a Friday). We all ordered steaks. I ordered a petite filet mignon. Not the best EVER, but decent. Their prices aren't outrageous (I think the steak was $24), but everything is a'la carte, with the exception of a side salad, which is included with the entree. (Salad was okay, nothing to talk about.) I ordered their cheese potatoes as my side, which were good. The wine list there doesn't offer anything exceptional or unusual, but it's also very reasonable.
We also recently went to Nonno Pino's, which I notice no one mentioned. Again, this is not world-class Italian, but everything on the menu looked good, and everything we had was pretty good. We had an appetizer the waitress recommended that were these fried bits stuffed with cheese and artichokes -- amazingly GOOD. I will say that I ordered a veal-stuffed tortellini, and the sauce was a bit rich for my taste. However, there were about five other entrees I would have tried and would go back to try. The interior of the place unfortunately looks a bit like a chain restaurant trying to look like a unique neighborhood place (ironic, no?) and our server was a little flaky, but for the prices, I was not disappointed at all with this place. They also have a large selection of wines by the glass.
That all being said, after reading every one else's recs, I definitely want to go try Zia's now.
-- Nora --
"Great food is like great sex. The more you have the more you want." ~Gael Greene