eatchicago wrote:I am not particularly price sensetive at the sub-$100-for-two level, but the final bill was well beyond what I thought the meal was worth. The antipasti had no business being in double-digit-dollar territory (one of them approaching $20).
I am price sensitive, even at the sub-$100-for-two level, but I didn't find tonight's dinner at Terragusto overpriced. I was, however, thankful to have the above reports to tailor our meal appropriately.
We skipped the
secondi and made a meal of two of the larger
antipasti and two
primi/pasta dishes. The food was absolutely terrific. You often hear that Italian cooking is about excellent ingredients, simply prepared. With these four dishes, Terragusto delivered.
The fried polenta with sauteed asparagus and mushrooms was delightful...crisp-fried buttery polenta, creamy on the inside. The asparagus was some of the best I've ever had...delicate in flavor, complementary to the 'shrooms and polenta, and not a hint of the stringy, stalky texture that can sometimes accompany this veggie.
The antipasti platter had a cucumber and mint salad, marinated mushrooms, tomato confit (or so it seemed), a diced tomato salad, and mozzarella di bufala, accompanied by some toasted baguette slices. The mozzarella was absolutely heavenly, especially matched with the confit-ed tomato, but the whole plate was nicely balanced, exceptionally fresh, and delivered an exactly appropriate amount of food and flavor.
We held off until after the appetizers to decide whether the pork chop would be a necessary supplement to the pasta. It wasn't.
We both had tagliatelle, my wife the bolognese and mine (whole wheat) with mushrooms, leeks, and fennel. The bolognese was good...bolognese is just a damn fine sauce, and Terragusto executed it superbly. In both dishes the pasta itself was wonderful. I probably wouldn't order tagliatelle sauced as I had it again. It was too salty (over-pecorinoed perhaps) and I didn't really perceive the fennel. Despite these shortcomings, it was a good dish, but it couldn't match the quality of the bolognese sauce, and I would rather try something new next time around. Overall, 3 of 4 dishes were outstanding, the fourth just pretty good.
Pasta helpings are not Buca di Beppo, or Caro Mio, but I didn't think they were small enough (especially with these rich dishes) to warrant the underlined
quality over quantity cards that were oddly stuffed into our napkins. Again though, the reports above prepared me for the "this is what we do" spiel, and it didn't bother me much at all.
We brought home some leftover tagliatelle, both left full, and spent about $70, 20%+ tip included. For the quality of the food, and the added bonus of supporting a place devoted to local, seasonal, organic eats, I actually thought the value was quite good, even though the prices aren't low.
An added note...when making a reservation this afternoon, I asked the host to recommend a wine to bring that he thought would complement the menu, obviously without knowing what we were going to order. He recommended a Valpolicella (which was nice, as I've been on a small Valpolicella kick), and it was a nice recommendation. Specifically, we brought a Negraro Valpolicella Ripassato 2002. Quite nice.