Just wanted to take a moment to offer my experience at Volo. We went here yesterday for dinner. It differed a little bit from those who wrote about it in this thread, but take it as you will.
A note on the service: generally good. First of all, we made a reservation at the last minute, and they were very accommodating about getting us in that night. I appreciated that. Our server wasn't super-fast, but we never felt like we were waiting an inordinately long amount of time. We also had our menus so long that, eventually, I put them down by my purse until we'd ordered everything. The only other "hiccup" was getting our San Pellegrino with ice in the glass (which we asked them to omit). Not a huge deal by any means, since we'd ordered the water from a different server.
We sat out on the back (covered) patio which has a nice ambiance. There are four little semi-private areas you can sit in with low tables, and regular 4-tops spread throughout. We sat at a regular table since we knew we'd be eating a full meal. The tables are a little small for a group of 4, considering at one point we had 12 glasses on the table, plus plates & silverware, plus the dishes. Still, it was nice to be on the patio.
Onto the food:
I liked the bread service. The bread was warm and soft, and the garlic-infused olive oil was very good. However, those little cups they put the oil in makes it really difficult to pour it on your plate without spilling it (!) Or maybe we're all just klutzy, I don't know.
We ordered four small plates, which came out mostly individually, so we were able to sample off each plate as they came. Our first was the cheese plate, and we got the six-cheese option. I thought everything on the plate was really good with one exception, and I think that was just a taste thing. After the cheese plate came mussels, which were in a garlic and butter sauce. I personally found the mussels to be very good; not really "fishy," if you will.
After that, we received our order of brioche with sake-scented apple compote and "complimentary" foie gras. (What can I say? I love ordering illegal food.) This was probably the weakest part of the meal, in my opinion. The foie gras was served very cold and was much more firm in texture than I am accustomed to. I'm certainly not a foie gras or pate expert, however, so it's hard for me to say whether that was odd. (Maybe they still doing the cured foie gras that
GWiv spoke of in the OP?) What was odd to me was the taste of the foie gras, which had an almost "freezer-burn" taste to it, as if a) it wasn't fresh, and b) it had been sitting in the back of the freezer for too long. It was actually my friend who pointed this fact out, and I realized he would probably remember what foie gras generally tastes like, because he'd been to the Sweets and Savories foie gras dinner with me. (Other than that, we're not particularly goose liver aficionados.)
After that, we received our order of bone marrow, which none of us had ever had before, and we decided to give a go. The bone marrow actually came out just like in
GWiv's picture at the top of this post. I'd have to say that bone marrow is probably ... an acquired taste, if at all. It definitely had a meaty, interesting flavor to it (one friend compared it to beef jerky). I don't know if I can pinpoint what it reminded me of, but it's probably not something I would ever make the effort to order again. I don't think it was poorly prepared. Just not my cup of tea.
I was still hungry at that point, so we went ahead and ordered entrees after that. I ordered the crispy quail with tempura green beans, baby greens, and a maple-pomegranate sauce. My biggest argument about the entrees is that, for their price, they really weren't much bigger than the small plates. The quail was fairly decent, very juicy and tender, though it was covered in a tempura-breading similar to the green beans, which kind of seemed unnecessary. I liked the green beans, but overall felt that they had been a bit too skimpy on the sauce, which really gave a really nice accent to the rest of the dish.
The DH ordered lamb chops, which came with a blue-cheese gratin. I can't remember the entire description of the plate. He seemed relatively content with that, again, his only complaint being the small portion. The lamb chops themselves were baby chops, and there were only two of them. I'm not generally a portion-complainer, but when I asked to try a little bit of his, he balked, given how much he had to work with. (He did eventually hand over a small portion, which I felt was decent.)
My friend ordered the pumpkin-ginger soup off the small plates menu for her entree, which, when served, had (what we thought was) a balsamic swirl running through it. This made for lovely presentation, but the soup was less than savory, really. We all had a little taste. It just didn't quite work.
My other friend ordered a flatbread pizza with fingerling potatoes and mushrooms and maybe goat cheese (?) I'm not exactly sure what was on it, but it was definitely an excellent choice.
Since I haven't commented on it yet: the wine. I, myself, only had a little bit of wine, but my friends both ordered flights and the DH had a couple glasses. I think all of us were impressed by the wine. Good choices, decent price point -- probably the highlight of the meal, really.
Overall, my feelings about this place is that, while it wasn't awful, it was just okay. If I was in the area and wanted a place to get some decent wine and a couple small plates, yes. However, I couldn't see myself making this a destination choice again.
-- Nora --
"Great food is like great sex. The more you have the more you want." ~Gael Greene