I searched, we don't have a dedicated thread to Bachelor Parties.
I'm putting together an email for the bachelor, going to lay out the places I think will be a good fit for the group (and especially for him).
Large group, some picky, non-adventurous eaters. Obviously, loud, fun, jovial, view, atmosphere can all be important. I've leaned pretty heavily to steakhouses, trying to break out of that without going too far "out there" for people who would think Sepia is too far "out there."
Here are the places I have laid out so far:
Nacional 27
Nine
Gibson's
David Burke's
Gene and Georghetti's
Custom House
What else would you add?
edit:
I'll add that I've been to a bachelor party at Red Light, which is a decent asian-influenced bachelor party dinner for a big group.
Not having been to Alhambra - would that make sense? Assuming the food is pretty vanilla?